LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 



0014 1125783 



F 122 
.D647 
Copy 1 




No. 136- 



I ASSEMBLY, APEIL 6, Mi 



From fhe Siicretar^ of State, in ansirer to resolutions re 
qumug .aformation in relation to the CZZlti 

STATE OF NEW-YOEK : 

Secretary's Office, ) 
Mbany, April 6t/i, 1854. \ 
To fhe Honorable the Assembly of the State of Mew-York: 

The undersigned in answer to two several resolutions of your 
honorable body the one bearing date on the 6th day of February 

«' ^t^^ ^^ '''' '''-' '-' '' ^-^^ ^-^-^' ^^^- ^-e 

REPORT : 

Jei]Tu!fT, 1 "' ^-""'-'-^ History have ever bee. or- 
dered by ihe Sei^ate, except those ordered by tlie resolution of 
January ,3th, 1849, ordering twenty times the usual nu^be^ 

That from a careful examination of all the resolutions by which 
hey have been ordered, commeneiug with that of January 4th, 

pea. that t.ere have been ordered in all, thirty-two thousand sU 

tundred ami eleven copies of the first volume ; twenty-four thou- 

sand seven hundred and twenty-one copies of the second volume ; 

lAssembly, No. 136.1 i , 

' ' 111.] 



2 [Assembly 



thirty-one thousand five hundred and thirty-one copies of the third 

voluoie, and eight thousand one hundred and fifty-one copies of 
the fourth vohime — making in all ninety-seven thousand and 
fourteen volumes. 

By the terms of the resolutions ordering such printing, said vol- 
umes were respectively awarded as follows : 

Of the first volume there were awarded to the Regents of the 

University, 1 ,300 volumes . 

To the Secretary of State, ,.>^... /, 1,000 « 

Legislature, 26,200 " 

Officers and reporters of Legislature, . . 3,680 " 
Governor and State officers, under the 

joint rules, 431 " 

32,611 " 

Of the second volume there were awarded. 

To the Eegents of the University, 100 " 

Secretary of State, 500 " 

Legislature, 20,200 " 

Officers and reporters thereof, 3,490 " 

Governor and State officers, 431 " 

24,721 « 

Of the third volume there were awarded. 

To the Regents of the University, 200 " 

Secretary>)f State, 500 "■ 

Legislature, 26,200 '' 

Officers and reporters thereof, 4,200 " 

Governor and State officers, under the 

joint rules, 431 " 

31,531 " 

Of the fourth volume there were awarded, 

To the Regents of the University, 000 '^ 

Secretary of State, 000 " 

Legislature, , 6,400 " 



No. 136.] 



Officers and reporters thereof, 1 ,580 " 

Governor and State officers, 171 " 

8,151 " 

In all, .... 97,014 " 



It will be observed that the resolution passed in the Assembly 
on the 7th day of April, 1853, ordering twenty copies to the mem- 
bers and officers of the Assembly of (hat year, became inopera- 
tive under the joint rules of that year, and the volumes ordered 
by that resolution were therefore not.printed. 

There were one thousajid copies of tlie first volume, and live 
tiundred copies of the second and third volumes each, awarded 
to the Secretary of State by his name of office, but none of the 
fourth volume. 

There were, in like manner, awarded to the Eegents of the 
University, one thousand copies of the first volume j all the other 
•volumes awarded to the Governor, or any of the State officers, or 
*he Regents of the University, were by virtue of the joint rules. 

And the undersigned further reports, that in order to ascertain 
'Correctly the number of copies cf each volume which has been 
published, he addressed a note to the publisher of the same, 
Charles Van Bentliuysen, Esq., and a copy of his answer to the 
«ame is hereto annexed, marked (A.) From this reply it seems 
that there have been published of the several volumes, including 
in each case three thousand volumes of tlie quart* edition, as 
follows, viz : 

Of the first volume, 29,422 copies. 

second " 30,000 '■ 

third " 27,678 '• 

fourth " 13,137 « 

In all, , 100,237 " 

•without including those ordered in the year 1853. The same 
liave all been distributed as the undersigned is informed and be- 



4 [Assembly 

lieves, except the few remaining in this office. There were re- 
maining here at the commencement of the present year, 
62 copies of the first volume, 
1,022 " second " 

781 " third " 

936 . " fourth " 



2,801, in all of both editions. 

All of which still remain here with the exception of one hun- 
dred and thirty-five copies of the third and fourth volumes of 
the quarto edition allotted to the Regents of the University by my 
predecessor, but not delivered till the present year, and three 
copies which have been presented by the undersigned' to public 
institutions of learning. 

That the records of this office furnish no evidence of the per- 
sons and institutions to whom the same have been delivered ; that 
most of them have, without doubt, been delivered to the persons 
to whom they were awarded by the several resolutions under and 
by virtue of wliich they were ordered, as but one individual 
only, to the knowledge of the undersigned, has ever claimed that 
any copies were still due to him under any one of said resolu- 
tions. That from two to three thousand sets of said work, by 
some means, but the great body of them without any authority 
of law, so far as appears to the undersigned, found their w^ay into- 
the office of the Secretary of State ; that they were never ordered 
for him or the State officers, or the Regents of the University,, 
farther than is above stated ; that their being here is, to the un- 
dersigned, a mystery which he has been entirely unable to solve f, 
that a*i account of their distribution will be iound in a commu- 
nication kindly furnished by my predecessor, and which is hereto^ 
annexed, marked (B.) 

It will also appear, by a communication from the secretary of 
the Board of Regents, that they have received from the publisher 
of the said history, five hundred copies of each volume of said 
history, although but one hundred copies of the second volume, 
two hundred of the third, and none of the fourth were awarded 
to them. 



No. 136.] 5 

Such communication, marked (C), is hereto annexed : 

That the undersigned has been unable to ascertain with accu- 
racy the cost of said work ; that the accounts for the same have 
now run through five years, and are so mixed up with charges for 
other printing, that it is a labor requiring much time, to separate 
the charges for this work only, and the undersigned has been 
unable to obtain, at the office of the Comptroller, an accurate 
statement of such cost ; that the undersigned can therefore but 
approximate to the real cost, but the estimate may perhaps be 
near enough for practical purposes. 

In the first volume of the Senate documents of 1852, document 
No. 5, will be found a report made by the late Comptroller, upon 
the cost of the volumes of the Documentary History ordered by 
the Assembly of 1851. Assuming the accuracy of that report, 
and it shows the cost of each volume of the work to be as follows : 

Each copy of the 1st volume, §1 C5 

do 2d do 171 

do 3d do 2 06 

do 4th do 2 24 

Omitting fractions. 

There have been published, of the first volume, exclusive of 
those ordered in the year 1853, and 3,000 of the quarto edition, 
26,422. 

These, at $1 .65 per volume, amount to $43 , 596 30 

Add, for 3,000 copies of the quarto edition, 9 ,000 00 

Total cost of the first volume, $52 , 596 30 



There have bsen published, of the second volume, excluding 
as above, 27,000 copies. 

These, at $1.71 per copy, amount to $46,170 00 

Add, for $3,000 copies quarto, 9,000 00 



Total expenses of second volume, $55 ,170 00 



6 [Assembly 

There have been published, of the third volume, excluding as 
above, 24,678. 

These, at $2.06 per copy, amount to $50 ,836 68 

Add, for 3,000 quartos, 9,000 00' 

Total expense of third volume, |59 ,836 68 

There have been published, of the fourth volume, excluding as 
above, 10,137 copies. 

These, at $2.24 per copy, cost $22 ,706 88 

Add, for 3,000 quartos, 9,000 00 

Total cost of fourth volume, $31 ,706 88 

The copies of the quarto edition are estimated at $3 per volume^ 
which probably falls short of the real expense ; but the under- 
signed has no means of arriving at a greater degree of accuracy. 

Provided these estimates were reliable, and they maybe regard- 
ed as an approximation near to the truth, they would show the' 
total expense of the Documentary History, exclusive of boxes 
and expense of transportation, to be as follows, viz.: 

Expenses of 1st volume, 29,422 copies, $52,596 30 

« 2d " 30,000 « 55,170 00 

" 3d " 27,678 " 59,836 68 

'; 4th « 13,137 « 31,706 88 

Total copies and expense, 100,237 $199,309 86 

The work has been printed by Chas. Van Benthuysen, Esq., to 
whom the money for the sane has been paid. 

The number of each edition in. this office on the first of Janu- 
ary, was as follows: 

Octavo edition, 1st volume, 7 copies. 

'« 2d " 865 " 

" 3d " 260 '' 

« 4th « 497 " 



No. 136.] 7 

Quarto edition, 1st volume, 55 copies. 

" 2d " 157 « 

« 3d " 521 " 

" 4th « 439 « 

All of which still remain in this office, except as is above 
stated. 

It appears from tlie foregoing facts that while 32,611 copies of 
the first volume have been ordered, only 29,422 copies have been 
printed; and that while only 24,721 copies of the second volume 
have been ordered, 30,000 copies have been printed; that 31,531 
copies of the third volume have been ordered, and only 24,678 
have been printed ; and that 8,1 51 only of the fourth volume have 
been ordered, and 13,137 have been printed. It further appears 
that while no copies of the fourth volume have been awarded to 
the Regents of the University, and only 100 copies of the second 
and 200 copies of the third volume, yet they have by some means 
received 500 copies of each of the four volumes. 

It also appears that there were awarded to the Secretary of 
State 1,000 copies of the first volume, 500 copies each of the se- 
cond and third volumes, and none of the fourth, yet he has re- 
ceived in all at least from three to four thousand copies of each 
volume. 

All of which is respectfully submitted, 

E. W. LEAVENWORTH, 

Sec'y of State, 
Albany^ April 6tk, 1854, 



(A. ) 

Albany, Feb. 1, 1854, 
E. W. Leavenworth, Esq., 

Secretary of Si ate: 
Dear Sir — Your favor of the 25th of JannarVjin relation to the 
number of copies of each voliirae of the Documentary History 
which has been published, &c., came duly to hand during my 
absence in New- York. 

The following is in answer to your inquiry, viz : 

Volume 1 , octavo edition; 20,423 copies. 

« 2, " 27,000 " 

« 3, " 24,678 « 

« 4, " 10,137 " 

Volumes 1,2,3, and 4, quarto edition, 3,000 copies each. 

The above comprises the entire editions delivered to the Legis- 
latures of 1849, 1850, 1851, and 1852. 

Respectfully yours, &c., 

C. VAN BENTHUYSEN, 

(B.) 

Cortland Village, March 4tli, 1854. 
Hon. Elias S. Leavenworth, 

Secretary of State: 
My Dear Sir — In pursuance of my ofler to give you the infor- 
mation in luy possession to enable you to comply with the resolu- 
tion of the House of Feb. 6th, calling on the Secretary of State for 
a statement of the number of volumes of the Documentary His- 
tory of New-York, printed by order of the House, from 1849 to 
1853 inclusive, to whom delivered, &c., I submit the following 



No. 136.] 9 

particulars of such information for the years 1852 and 1853, du- 
ring whicli I had the honor to be Secretary of State. 

I have not, in my possession, any account of the number of such 
volumes delivered by order of the House to its present and pre- 
vious members, or at the Secjetctry's office, during those years. 
This can of course be obtained by a comparison of such orders, 
with the vouchers of the printer to the Legislature. There were 
no full sets of either the octavo or quarto edition of the Docu- 
mentary History in the Secretary's office when I entered it, and, 
according to my recollection, no large number of the scattering 
volumes. Such as there were of these last, and such volumes as 
the printer subsequently delivered, were, tor a considerable pe- 
riod, furnished to proper persons applying for them, principally 
to those who had obtained a part of the volumes from my prede- 
cessor in office, without any list being kept of their names. I did 
not keep such a list, because it had not been customary in the 
office, because I was not required so to ut>, and because I then 
neither saw nor anticipated circumstances which rendered it ne- 
cessary or specially desirable. 

When I ascertained that the remaining volumes of the quarto 
edition were likely to be completed before the close of 1853, and 
that a large number of complete copies (say 2,500) would in that 
event be delivered at the Secretary's office, I felt it incumbent 
on me, in carrying out the presumed intentions of the Legisla- 
ture, to arrange some more systematic plan for their distribution. 
I use the words " presumed intentions," because I am not aware 
that the Legislature formally directed such distribution by the 
Secretary. But it steadily indicated its object in publishing the 
work, by annually making large popular distributions through 
its members and through all the officers of the House, and when 
it placeil otlier copies in the possesbion of that officer of the gov- 
ernment who had gratuitously supervised the completion and 
publication, the then Secretary of State, who was personally cog- 
nizant of and had advised in all the legishitive action in the pre- 
mises, construed it to be the intention of the Legislature that he 
should distribute such copies. He acted on this construction for 
as many as two years, and until the close of his term of office, 



10 [Assembly 

with the full knowledge of succeeding Legislatures and of the 
public. He did so not only without objection from any quarter, 
but additional quantities of the work were from time to time de- 
livered to him, if I mistake not, in pursuance of repeated resolu- 
tions of the House, or, at all events, when a resolution of that 
body would at any time have changed the destination of the 
books, or corrected any mistake into which the Secretary had 
fallen in regard to the proper distribution of them. 

Regarding the above facts as entirely conclusive of the inten- 
tions of the Legislature in the premises, I proceeded, at the pe- 
riod already stated, to fix upon such a plan of distribution as I 
believed would best attain the philanthropic objects of that body 
in publishing the work, and best subserve the public interests. 
To this end, I determined, first, to place a copy of it in every 
public library in the State, excepting those of common schools 
and higher literary institutions. The former were very reluct- 
antly passed over, because all ths sets of the work at my dispo- 
sal fell short of one-fourth of their number, and no method of 
discriminating between them was perceived which would be 
either satisfactory to the inhabitants of the excluded districts, or 
just in itself. The higher institutions did not require them, being 
supplied by the Regents of the University. Anticipating that a 
much larger number of public libraries, other than the preceding, 
would be found in the State, than actually were found, I further 
determined, should it become necessary, to make a discrimina- 
tion in favor of those established for the benefit of that portion 
of our population to whom, as a general thing, historical collec- 
tions are less accessible. To carry out the above views, as soon 
as the number of full sets received in my oflace rendered it ex- 
pedient to. commence the distribution, I dispatched the following 
circular into all such parts of the State, as from density of popu- 
lation or other causes, I thought were likely to contain public 
libraries : 

Secretary's Office, ^ 
Albany, Oct. 17M, 1853. J 

Dear Sir — Will you be good enough to inform me what perma- 
nent and respectable literary or scientific association, or any 
others whose object is mental culture, (and especially associa- 



No. 136.] 11 

tions of mechanics and other laboring men,) there are in your 
town, which have well regulated libraries for the use of their 
members or the public ? 

I inquire, because I have some sets of the Documentary Histo- 
ry of New-York (4 vols.) to distribute ; and I think it better to 
give them to such institutions, where permanent in their charac- 
ter, than to individuals. I shall, in all cases, give preference to 
associations of laboring men, though I may have enough to distri- 
bute among those of a different class. 

Give name of president, librarian, or some other officer, to 
whom the books will be directed in case I can send them. 

I am sir, very respectfully, 

HENRY S. RANDALL. 

In answer to the above, not to exceed two hundred and twenty 
libraries of any kind were reported, and not more than one hun- 
dred and fifty of these were of the class contemplated in the cir- 
cular. A few union and district school libraries stated to be 
used by a numerous population of all ages, and to take the place 
of " public libraries," and some college and academy libraries 
which had failed to receive the work from the Regents of the 
University, or subsequently lost it, were brought to my notice, 
and all such were included in the distribution. A number of 
libraries of religious, charitable and other associations were also 
reported, which in some instances probably prescribe peculiar 
conditions of admission which, in point of fact, may be said to 
necessarily exclwde large portions of the community from their 
benefits, aud which therefore cannot be considered public, even 
in that loose sense in which this designation is applied to town or 
literary association libraries, the first of which are confined 
to the use of single towns, and the last, frequently to a prescrib- 
ed number of members. But if denominational, professional and 
other peculiar tests of admission, were considered fatal to the 
claims of a library, it would exclude those of some of the most 
philanthropic, useful and best conducted institutions of the State. 
Having a surplus of the books, and believing that the library of 
any association w^ould give a wider publicity to their contents 



12 [Assembly 

than the library of a single individual, I decided to send them to 
all the associations reported in answer to my circular, believed to 
be composed of respectable and intelligent men, and intended for 
the melioration of man in any particular, without constituting 
myself a judge of the means employed for that purpose. " The 
whole number of copies of the Documentary History sent to 
public or association libraries, of any description, was about two 
hundred, and the names of one hundred and thirty-two of these 
will be found in the annexed list. 

I next wrote or personally requested, individuals in various 
parts of the State, to furnish me lists for their county or a wider 
locality, of "a few of the clergy, editors, literary men, artists, 
teachers, physicians, lawyers, mechanics, merchants, farmers and 
men in all other avocations, without respect to party, creed, or 
school, who would be likely to put the Documentary History of 
the State, to the best use for themselves and the public." These 
enquiries drew very full replies from some quarters, and very mea- 
gre ones from others ; in many instances no names being sent in but 
those of a few prominent public men, confined to one or two 
professions, and mainly to one. I then hit upon the plan ol 
writing persons, and requesting them to furnish the names of the 
most suitable men in their own professions or avocations, over as 
wide a portion of country as their acquaintance extended. These 
letters, like the preceding, were answered very fully in some 
cases, and neglected in others. In the mean time, my term ot 
office was drawing to a close, and I was obliged to pmceed with 
the distribution, or leave it, after expending so much labor and 
exciting so many expectations, half finished ; completed in some 
counties and scarcely commenced in others. Under such circum- 
stances I felt it my duty to proceed upon the best information in 
my possession, and I accordingly did so. 

About one hundred copies were delivered to other State officers, 
members of the Legislature and other prominent citizens, for 
distribution in their respective localities, no account of which 
appears in the annexed list. In several instances I recollect the 
extra number thus delivered ; but to guard against the additional 
chance of mistakes, I have preferred in all cases to adhere to ray 
original written lists and memoranda. This rule also prevents my 



No. 136.] 13 

now entering on the subjoining list the names of many members 
of the Legislature, who received the work, but whose names were 
not taken down among the others, incidentally recorded, because 
I expected to furnish every member with a copy, and a check 
mark, opposite their names in the Manual, was deemed sufficient. 
Neither of these marked copies of the Manual is now in my pos- 
session. 

Outside of the above exceptions, the list is still deficient in the 
names of some who received the work. 1 should remark, that 
my only object in keeping a list at[all, was for my guidance in 
carrying out my plan of distribution, and for my own future re- 
ference, should curiosity prompt it. I did not in the least con- 
template any occasion which would render its preservation desir- 
able for the information of others. While I therefore used such 
care for this purpose, as the above motives suggested, I did not 
regard it as an official paper or statement, which it was any part 
of my official duty to preserve. Many of my lists, made up from 
an inspection of my daily correspondence, were written from 
necessity on slips of paper, when I was confined to a sick bed, 
and were thus sent to the office. A portion of these were scat- 
tered and lost before I recovered sufficiently and found time among 
delayed and urgent duties, to attend to their preservation. The 
names below include all preserved on my written lists, and they 
designate the recipients of two thousand, one hundred and nine 
copies of the work. 

Owing to causes already stated, my original plan of distribution 
has not, doubtless, in all cases been perfectly carried out. Eut 
how far and how fairly it has been done, the annexed paper will 
show, which I must cheerfully enclose to you, to enable you to 
answer, so far as my term of office was concerned, the enquiries 
of the Legislature. 

I have omitted to mention, that, believing it Avould conduce to 
the interest and reputation of our State, I distributed about one 
hundred and seventy-five copies of the Documentary History 
among citizens of other States. The names of the individuals 
receiving them, will be found below. 

I have the honor to be, my dear sir, very respectfully, your 
obedient servant, HENRY S. RANDALL. 



14 j Assembly 

List of associations, libraries a7^d individuals to whom Documentary 
History of JYew-York was sent by Henry S. Randall, Secretary of 
State, during the years 1852 and 1853 : 

West Troy Young Men's Association, Troy. 

Mechanics' Library Association, Elraira. 

Union School Library, Morrisville. 

Oswego Library, (being founded,) Oswego. 

Richland Library Association, Pulaski. 

Naval Lyceum, Brooklyn. 

Brooklyn City Library, Brooklyn. 

Youth's Free Library, « 

Brooklyn Atheneum, " 

Brooklyn Law Library, <« 

Library of Lyceum, Chatham Four Corners. 

Franklin Libraiy Association, Hudson. 

Public Library of Greene, Greene. 

Library of Mechanics' Society School of Crosby street, New- 
York. 

Mechanics' Library, corner Bowery and Division streets, New- 
York. 

Apprentices Library, New- York. 

Hamilton Literary Association, Brooklyn. 

Durhamville Public Library, (being founded,) Durhamville. 

Middletown Lyceum, Middletown. 

Mechanics' Library Association, Canandaigua. 

Franklin Institute, Syracuse. 

Truxton Library Association, Truxton. 

Pooghkcepsie Lyceum, Poughkeepsie. 

Public Library of Poughkeepsie, Poughkeepsie. 

Young Men's Association, « 

Philomathean Society of Hamilton Academy, Hamilton. 

Buffalo Female Seminary, Buffalo. 

Young Men's Washington Association, Penn Yan. 

Young Men's Association, Ogdensburgh. 

Mechanics' Institute, New- York. 

Library of Debating Club, Charlotte Centre. 

Young Men's Association, Binghamtou. 

Vernon Literary Association, Vernon. 



No. 136.] 15 

Union Society of Hamilton College, Clinton. 
Operatives in Utica steam mills, Utica. 
Phcenix Society of Hamilton College, Clinton. 
Young Men's Association, Palmyra. 
Public Library ot Waterville, Waterville. 
Deposite Seminary Library, Deposite. 
Franklin Library, Cooperstown. 
Library Association of Havana, Havana. 
Tompkins Lyceum, Stapleton. 
• Library of Staten Island Battallion, Stapleton. 
Ladies Library of Scipioville, Scipioville. 
Galen Mechanical and Historical Association, Clyde. 
Mechanics' Library, Nunda. 
Young Men's Association, Schenectady. 
Rondout Literary Association, Rondout. 
Mechanics' Association, Waverly. 

Philomathean Society of St. Lawrence Academy, Pottsdam. 
Literary Association, (being organised,) " 

Library of village of Setauket, Setauket, 
Library of Coxsackie, Coxsackie. 
Young Men's Association, Troy. 
Philomathean Society, Union College, Schenectady. 
Adelpliia Society, Union College, Schenectady. 
Medina Lyceum, Medina. 

Public Library of Eiiskirk's bridge, Buskirk's bridge. 
Hoosic Falls Library, Hoosic Falls. 
Library of People's College, (care H. Howard,) Lockport. 
Mechanics' Institute, Crosby street, New-York. 
Apprentices' Library, Chambers St., " 
Printer?' Library, " 

Mercantile Library, Beekman st., " 

New- York Law Institute, ?« 

American Institute, " 

Lyceum of Natural History, " 

New-York Chamber of Commerce, " 

Young Men's Association, Lockport. 
Irving Association, Blanchport. 
Reading Club, Liberty. 



16 [Assembly 

Canastota Library Society, Canastota. 

New-York Geographical Society, New-York. 

New- York Historical Sociely 5 " 

Here a leaf is gone from the original list. 

Adams Scientific and Military Association, Adams. 

Weedsport Union School, Weedsport. 

Library of Union School, Geneva. 

Young Men's Christian Union, Buffalo. 

School District No. 22, Ogdensburgh. 

District School Library, Baldwinsville. • 

School District No. 2, Yonkers. 

Blooomingdale Insane Asylum, Bloomingdale. 

School District No. 23, New-York. 

School Dist. Library, Valatie. 

School Dist. Library, Cooperstown. 

School Dist. Library, Cherry Valley. 

School Dist. Library, New RDchelle. 

Union School Library, Mt. Morris. 

School Dist. Library, Lowville. 

School Dist. Library, Glens Falls. 

Union School Library, Newark. 

Union School Library, Camden. 

School Dist. Library, Fulton. 

School Dist. Library, Bridgehampton. 

School Dist. Library, Rosendale. 

Library of Dental College, Syracuse. 

Union Theological Seminary Library, New- York. 

Episcopal Theological Seminary Library, " 

St. Joseph's Theological Seminary Library, " 

Library of Mt. St. Vincent Sisters of Charity, New- York. 
College of St. Francis Xavier, " 

Presbyterian Board of Missions, " 

Episcopal Board of For. and Dom. Missions, N. Y 
Academy of the Sacred Heart, 
St. Paul's Female Orphan Asylum, 
St. Vincent's Hospital, 
American Bible Society, 
Young Men's Christian Association, 



No. 136.1 17 

Library of St. Catherine's Covenant of the Sisters of Mercy j 
New-York. 

St. John's College, New- York. 

Union School, Lockport. 
St. Mary's Library Asssociation, Albany. 
St. Joseph's Library " 

Elmira Baptist Library Association, Elmira. 
Adelphic Society of Madison University, Hamilton. 
Library of Medical College, Geneva. 
Literary Association, Cincinnatus. 
Union Society Association, Scott. 
Young Men's Institute, (Corning) Corning. 
College Library, Rochester. 
Clarkson Academy, Clarkson. 
U. S. Military Academy, West Point. 
Zanesville Alheneum, Zanesville, Ohio. 
College Library, Princeton, New-Jersey. 
Brown's University, Providence, Rhode Island. 
Washington College, Pennsylvania. 
Fisk Free Library, New-Orleans, La. 
University of Vermont, Burlington. 
Connecticut Historical Society, Hartford. 
Masons' Library, Cayuga. 
Odd Fellows' Library, Liberty. 
Theological Seminary, Auburn. 
Hon. Hamilton Fish, (10 copies,) New- York. 
Hon. Washington Hunt, (10 copies,) Lockport. 
Hon. Horatio Seymour, (10 copies,) Albany. 
Hon. Erastus Corning, " 

Hon. Nicholas Hill, « 

Hon, John C. Spencer, " 

Hon. Robert H. Pruyn, " 

Hon. Amasa J. Parker, " 

Hon. D. D. Barnard, " 

Hon. Samuel Stevens, " 

Hon; John C. Wright, « 

Hon. Levi S. Chatlield, " 

Harman Pompelly, Esq. " 

[Assembly, No. 136.1 2 



18 [Assembly 

Amos Dean, Esq. Albany. 

J. B. Plumb, Esq. a 

Hon. Wm. W. Forsyth, « 

Thomas W. Olcott, Esq., « 

Gen. Robert E, Temple, , « 

Hon. Bradford R. Wood, « 

Hon. Eli Perry, u 

Re7. Dr. John N. Campbell, " 

Rev. Dr. Wm. B. Sprague, « 

Rt. Rev. Bishop Kip, u 

Rev. Dr. Ray Palmer, « 

Rt. Rev. Bishop McClosky, « 

Rev. Mr. Conroy, « 

Rev. Dr. Horatio Potter, «« 

Rev. Dr. Henry N. Polhman, « 

Rev. Dr. Duncan Kennedy, « 

Rev. Dr. Isaac N. Wyckoff, " 

Rev. E. P. Wadhams, « 

Rev. T. Doran, u 

Rev. E. Devoll, u 

Dr. James McNaughton^ " 

Dr. Alden March, u 

Dr. J. H. Armsby, u 

Dr. J. P. Boyd, u 

Dr. E. H. Emmons, « 

Dr. Howard Townsend, « 

Dr. R. H. Thompson, « 

Dr. J. H. Salisbury, « 

Dr. Thomas Hun, « 

Henry H. Martin, Esq., « 

Lewis Benedict, Esq., « 

Lewis Benedict, Jr., Esq., « 

Henry H. Van Dyck, Esq., « 

William Cassidy, Esq., « 

John Rowland, Esq., u 

M. H. Rooker, Esq., « 

Thurlow Weed, Esq., « 

George Dawson, Esq., a 



Wo. 136.] 19 

Frederick W. Seward, Esq., Albany. 

Visscher Ten Eyck, Esq., " 

Sherman Croswell, Esq., ■** 

James I. Johnson, Esq., " 

Samuel Hammond, Esq., ** 

L. S. Hammond, Esq., " 

James Kidd, Esq., <* 

Carlton Edwards, Esq., " 

J. Stanley Smitli, Esq., « 

Hugh Hastings, Esq., " 

Hon. Rufus W. Peckham, *' 

Hon. D. B. St. John, « 

Theodore Townsend, Esq., *' 

John Townsend, Esq., ^^ 

Col. W. H. F. Walker, « 

Peter Cagger, Esq., <' 

George Dexter, Esq., " 

Jacob I Werner, Esq., " 

Ezra P. Prentice, Esq., ** 

Eufus H. King, Esq., « 

Anthony Gould, Esq.,, " 

William Gould, Esq., « 

John B. James. Esq., " 

Benjamin Tibbits, Esq., " 

John N. Wilder, Esq., « 

Charles L. Austin, Esq.. ^* 

J. B. Brinsmade, Esq., " 

'Rufus G. Beardsley, " 

Gen. P. Gansevoort, « 
John Knower, Esq,, " 

John McKnight, Esq., « 

Hon. R. J. Hilton, « 

Andrew J. Colvin, Esq., " 

Prof. Julian Molinard, " 

Archibald Campbell, Esq., " 
Alexander Campbell, Esq.. (in Chili,) " 

Col. Isaac Vanderpool, " 
Alfred B. Street, Esq., " 

Anthony Blanchard, Esq., " 



20 



[Assemble 



Dudley Burwell, Esq., Albany. 

Matthew McMahon, Esq., " 

John 0. Cole, Esq., " 

W. A. Livingston, Esq., " 

Amos Pillsbury, Esq., " 

Otis Allen, Esq., « 

Hon. Gideon Hawley, " 

John H. Reynolds, Esq., " 

John K. Porter, Esq., " 

Hon. Azor Taber, " 

Hon. Charles S. Benton, " 

Marcus T. Reynolds, Esq., "• 

-Dl'. Wilber, (Lunatic Asylum.,) " 

Luther Tucker, Esq., '^ 

-Benj'n P. Johnson, Esq., '^ 

Hon. Bradford R. Wood, (for son,) " 

Hon. Alexander S. Johnson, " 

E. D. Palmer, Esq., « 

Clinton Cassidy, Esq., «'■ 

Duncan Campbell, Esq., '^ 

Hon. Franklin Townsend, «' 

Robert Townsend, Esq., " 

Wm. A. Perkins, Esq., "^ 

Samuel B. Woolworth, Esq., " 

George W. Newell, Esq., " 

Jeremiah Osborne, Esq., « 

Hon. W. J. Mc Alpine, (5 copies,) " 
Regents of the University, (135 copies,)* " 
Hon. John A. Dix, New- York. 

Hon. Heman J. Redfield, •« 

Hon. Greene C. Bronson, « 

Hon. John Van Buren, " 

Hon. Charles 0' Conor, « 

Hon. Augustus Schell, « 

Hon. Azariah C. Flagg, u 

Hon. Joseph S. Bos worth, « 

Hon. George Bancroft, a 

' For distribution among Colleges, Academies, States, and Territories, according to law. 



No. 136.J 



21 



Hon. Benjamin F. Butler, 
Hon. Nathaniel B. Blunt, 
Hon. James T. Brady, 
William C. Bryant, Esq., 
Hon. Robert J. Dillon, 
Hon. John W. Edmonds, 
Hon. Henry P. Edwards, 
Hon. David Dudley Field, 
Hnn. Ambrose L. Jordan, 
Hon. William Kent, 
Hon. Samuel J. Tilden, 
Hon. John C. Hamilton, 
Hon. A. W. Bradford, 
Hon. Hiram Ketchum, 
Alexander Hamilton, jr., 
William B. Astor, Esq., 
Hon. Ransom H. Glllet, 
Hon. Isaac V. Fowler, 
Hon. John Cochrane, 
•Hon. George Wood, 
Hon. John J. Cisco, 
Hon. J. Romeyn Brodhead, 
Hon. Mike Walsh, 
Hon. Daniel E. Sickles, 
Hon. Wm. Mc Murray, 
Parke Godwin, Esq., 
George D. Butler, Esq., 
John E. Develin, Esq., 
Andrew Carrigan, Esq., 
Hoe. Edward E. Cowles, 
J. C. H. Waddell, Esq., 
Richard Connolly, Esq., 
Michael Hoffman, Esq., 
Cambridge Livingston, Esq.. 

Jordan^ Esq., 

Andrew H. Green, Esq., 
Prof. Horace Webster, 
John Bigelow, Esq., 
Isaac Townsend, Esq., 



New-York. 



u 
a 
(( 
<( 
u 
(( 
u 
u 
u 
(I 

IC 

a 

« 

a 

(I 

tt 

u 

ii 

u 

II 

II 

a 

u 
u 
(I 
u 
tt 
tt 
n 
(t 
tl 
tt 
II 
It 
tl 



22 



[Assemble 



Francis Griffin, Esq., 




New- York, 


George H. Purser, Esq., 




« 


Fitz Greene Hal leek, Esq., 


u 


Family of John Targee, Esq.^ 


ti 


Gen. George P, Morris, 




u 


Henry James, Esq., 




a 


Thomas K. Downiug, Esq., 


u 


Nelson J. Waterbury, Esq., 


» 


Albert Gilbert, Esq., 




u 


Hon. William Jay, 




11 


Ambrose Stevens, Esq,, 




ii 


Hon. Ogden Edwards, 




u 


Samuel Hueston, 




u 


Thomas N. Rocker, Esq. 


) 


u 


Bayard Taylor, Esq., 




ii 


Charles L. Ellicott, artisty 


ii 


George A. Baker, 


a 


u 


Daniel Huntington, 


u 


Ii 


Thomas Hicks, 


u 


it 


Henry Peters Gray, 


a 


(( 


Louis Lacey, Esq., 


u 


;( 


Abram B. Durand, 


u 


(( 


J. T. Cropsey, 


u 


ii 


John T. Kensett, 


u 


a 


Frederick E. Church, 


Or 


ii 


D. W. C. Boutelle, 


U 


t,i 


F. B. Carpenter, 


a 


11 


Thomas Doughty, 


u 


11 


Jessee Talbot, 


u 


« 


T. Addison Richards, 


a 


(( 


Colman, Esq., 


a 


tc 


R. W. Hubbard, Esq., 


ii 


ii 


Thomas P. Rossiter, 


a 


(( 


William Page, 


u 


C{ 


George .James, 


u 


(( 


E. W. Nichols, 


u 


(( 


Emmanuel Leutze, 


u 


(( 


Edwin White, 


u 


a 



No. 136.] 23 



William H. Powell, artist. 


New- York, 


Most Revd. Abp. Hughes, 


(C 


Rt. Rev. Bp. B. T. Onderdonk, 


(( 


Rev. Gardiiier Spring, 


(C 


Rev. S. H. Tyng, 


ii 


Rev. Francis Hawks, 


u 


Rev. WiHiam Berrian, 


ii 


Rev. Bangs, 


li 


Rev. T. W. Chambers, 


ii 


Rev. Thomas De Witt, 


ii 


Rev. Augustus A. Wood, 


ii 


Rev. S. H Cone, 


ii 


Rev. Edward Lathrop, 


ii 


Rev. G. B. Cheever, 


ii 


Rev. Henry Cheever, 


11 


Rev. David Bellamy, 


a 


Rev. Joseph Thompson, 


it 


Rev. S. Busche, 


a 


Rev F. F. Cornell, 


a 


Rev. John S. Ebaugh, 


a 


Rev. Isaac Ferris, 


a 


Rev. G. H. Fisher, 


a 


Rev. J. C. Guildin, 


ii 


Rev. J. B. Hardenburgh, 


a 


Rev. M. S. Kutton, 


it 


Rev. John Knox, 


a 


Rev. Jeremiah Lord, 


ii 


Rev. J. M. Macaulay, 


a 


Rev. N. J. Marsellus, 


it 


Rev. Enoch Van Aiken, 


it 


Rev. A. R. Van Nest, 


a 


Rev. C. Wiiitehead, 


it 


Rev. G. Cohen, 


a 


Rev. Maries Dendsiger, 


a 


Rev. Lehman Heitner, 


ii 


Rev. Theodore Boohn, 


a 


Rev. F. W. Geissenhamer, 


ii 


Rev. Valentine Buck, 


a 



24 [Assembly 



Rev. E. E. Griswold, 


New-York. 


Rev. Peter Ross, 


c< 


Rev. Thorns H. TayloPj 


a 


Rev. H. J. Whitehouse, 


u 


Rev. L. P. W. Balch, 


a 


Rev. G. T. Bedell, 


k 


Rev. George Potts, 


K 


Rev. A. E. Camptell, 


ti 


Rev. J. W. Cummings, 


ii 


Rev. Joseph Muller, 


u 


Rev. John Garretson, 


li 


Rev. Henry W. Bellows, 


ti 


Rev. William Balch, 


u 


Richard Schell, Esq., 


u 


F. E. Gelbort, Esq., 


u 


Hon. Robert Emmet, 


u 


Hon. J. Prescott HalJ, 


u 


Hon. John Jay, 


l( 


Hon. John Duer, 


» 


Hon. Jolm Anthon, 


« 


Hon. Ogden Hofiman, 


(( 


Col. D. E. Dele van, 


u 


Hon. Lutlier Bradish, 


ii 


Rufus Wilmot Griswold, D. D., 


(C 


Hon. Mill I home Tompkins, 


» 


Daniel D. Tompkins, Esq., 


u 


Hon. David O'Keefe, 


u 


J. Livingston, Esq., 


it 


W. B. Sliaw, Esq., 


u 


C. S. Tappen, Esq., 


u 


George P. Putnam, Esq., 


(C 


Messrs. D. Appleton & Co., 


« 


Messrs. Harper, 


C( 


Messrs. Wiley & Putnam, 


(( 


Messrs. Stringer & Townsend, 


u 


Charles W. Sandeis, Esq., 


(( 


Watts Sherman, Esq., 


u 



No. 136.1 



Hon. Abij.ili Mann, 


New- York 


Hon. Jfinies VV. Beekman, 


(( 


Hon. Edwin D. Morgan, 


(( 


Hon. Harvey P. Peet, 


<. 


Hon. J. A. Westervelt, 


u 


Hon. Will. W. Campbell, 


<i 


Samuel Cuhnan, Esq., 


<( 


Hon. A. H. Mickle, 


u 


Wm. L. Lawrence, Esq., 


a 


Hon. John P. Hale, 


u 


Ray Tompkins, Esq., 


a 


Wm. Ramsey, Esq., 


it 


Wm. Meiizies, Esq., 


a 


George S. Fox, Esq., 


<( 


Hon. Daniel Lord, 


(C 


Hon. John McKeon. 


u 


Hon. Wm. U Maclay, 


a 


Hon. Hugh Maxwell, 


« 


Hon. lv)lHri H. Morris, 


ii 


Hon. Tlioiuas J. Oakley, 


u 


Henry Nicoll, Esq., • 


a 


Henry R. Rem sen. Esq , 


u 


Charles H. Sanford, Esq., 


(C 


John B Scoles, Esq., 


<( 


Theodore Sedgwick, Esq., 


• u 


Edward Sanford, Esq., 


('. 


T.nTpn7(i 1{ Slipnard. "Flsn.. 


u 



Samuel Sherw^ood, Esq., " 

Seth P. Staples, Esq., " 

Hon. Frederick A. Tallmadge, " 

Charles Tracy, Esq., " 

Hon.DaidclUllman, « 

Hon. Josrpli B. Varnum, " 

Hon. Gillian C. Verplanck, " 

Edward C. West, Esq., '* 

Henry M. Western, Esq., " 

P. H. Mver.^Esq., « 

P. S. Hues, Esq., " 



26 [Assembly 



A. Varick, 


New-York, 


H. G. Carpenter, Esq., 


u 


Hon. James E. Cooley, 


• 


Hon. Edwin Croswell, 


<( 


Hon. Moses D. Gale, 


u 


Hon. G. F. Aldeu, 


u 


Hon. T. P. St. John, 


li 


John T. Henry, Esq., 


cc 


Robert McJimpsey, Esq., 


li 


George G. Sickles, Esq., 


C{ 


Hon. David L. Seymour, 


Troy. 


Hon. George R. Davis, 


li 


Hon. Job Pierson, 


(t 


AbramP. Olive, Esq., 


li 


Rev. Dr. N. S. S. Beeman, 


li 


Rev. Dr. G. C. Baldwin, 


u 


Hon. Gilbert Robinson, 


li 


Rev. M. Fields, 


11 


Rev. M. Lounsberry, 


It 


Rev. P. Havermans, 


11 


Hon. David Buel, Jr., , 


11 


J. A. Millard, Esq., 


a 


Hon. A. K. Hadley, 


11 


George B. Warren, Esq., 


li 


Joseph W. Warren, Esq., 


li 


S. K. Stow, Esq., 


11 


Tracy Taylor, Esq., 


11 


George Vail, Esq., 


11 


N. B. Squires, Esq., 


(( 


George Dauchy, Esq., 


ii 


Joel Mai lory, Esq., 


11 


George A. Griswold, Esq., 


li 


James W. Flack, Esq., 


11 


Seneca Bowers, Esq., 


li 


Richard Carter, Esq., 


it 


William Coany, E^q., 


(I 


Hon. T. B. Carrol, 


K 


McArthur, Esq., 


It 



No. 136.] 27 



Benjamin H. Hall, Esq., 


Troy. 


Gen. J. J. Veile, 


u 


Hon. Gardiner K. Stow, 


li 


Maj. Gen. John E. Wool, 


ii 


Fislv,Esq., 


u 


Hon. John C. Mather, 


u 


L page of Troy names is here gone 


from the o: 


Hon. Samuel Beardsley, 


Utica. 


Hiram Deuio, 


(( 


Samuel B. Garvin, 


(C 


Ward Hunt, 


(( 


Wm. J. Bacon, 


u 


Ezekiel Bacon, 


u 


Josluirt A. Spencer, 


u 


Charles A, Mann, 


it 


David Wagner, 


u 


A. B. Johnson Esq., 


u 


Francis K<rnian, Esq., 


u 


John B. Miller, Esq., 


(( 


RutgerB. Miller, Esq., 


(I 


P. Sheldon Root, Esq., 


t. 


John F. Seymour, Esq., 


u 


James Waisou Williams, Esq., 


u 


Thomas H. Hubbard, Esq., 


li 


Roscoe Conkling, Esq., 


11 


A. A. Boies, Esq., 


ii 


John G. Crocker, Esq., 


il 


Burton D. Hulburt, Esq., 


(( 


D. Bennet, Esq., 


(( 


Col. J. E. Herman, 


u 


Pomroy Jones, Esq., 


ii 


F. F. Curry, Esq., 


u 


E. A. Graliam,Esq., 


i( 


Theo. S. Faxon, Esq., 


u 


John Butterfield, Esq., 


u 


W. C. Churchill, Esq., 


IC 


Col. E. Jeweit, 


ii 



2S 



[Assembly 



i^r. woicoii, 

H. S. Cole, Esq., 


uuca. 


Egbert Bagg, JEsq., 


a 


Edward S. Erayton, Esq., 


11 


Hon. Philo Gridley, 


xc 


William Tracy, Esq., 


u 


Editor of the Baptist Register, 


ii 


J. Earl Hiirlbut, Esq., 


u 


W. S. Headley, Esq., 


(C 


Dr. John McCall, 


(( 


Dr. Benedict, (Lunatic Asylum) 


<c 


Editor of Observer, 


(( 


Rev. Mr. Fowler, 


(( 


Edward Huntington, Esq., 


Rome. 


Hon. Benjamin Huntington, 


« 


Calvert Comstock, Esq., 


<( 


Henry A. Foster, Esq., 


(( 


Alanson Bennet, Esq., 


(( 


John Stryker, Esq., 


(( 


Benjamin 11. Wrilght, Esq., 


ti 


S. W. Morton, Esq., 


u 


Hon. Wm. H. Shankland, 


Syracuse. 


B. Davis Noxon, 


11 


James R. Lawrence, 


u 


D. D. Hillis, Esq., 


u 


Jerome J. Briggs, Esq., 


n 


Harvey Rliodes, Esq., 


u 


Henry W. Sedgwick, Esq., 


u 


Charles A. Sedgwick, Esq., 


u 


Hon. Elias W. Leavenworth, 


u 


Hon. M. D. Burnett, 


(C 


Peter Outwater, Esq., 


u 


Harvey Baldwin, Esq., 


K 


Dennis McCarthy, Esq., 


a 


Horace Wheaton, Esq., 


(( 


Hon. James W. Nye, 


« 


Hon. Wm. J. Hough, 


<{ 


P. H. Agan, Esq., 


a 



No. 136.] 



39 



L. W. Hall, Esq., 


Syracuse, 


James S. Leach, Esq., 


u 


Vivus W. Smith, Esq., 


(( 


J. A. Sherman, Esq., 


a 


Rev. Samuel J. May, 


u 


Van R. Richmond, Esq., 


u 


Dr. A. B. Shipman, 


a 


Dr. Amos Westcott, 


ii 


Dr. David Matthews, 


u 


Stephen D. Dilaye, Esq., 


ii 


Jason C. Woodruff, Esq., 


11 


Seth Haight, Esq., 


u 


Nathan Randall, Esq., 


ii 


Clinton F. Paige, Esq., 


u 


John Barbour Barnett, Esq., 


u 


Orville C. Hartwell, Esq., 


<( 


Hon. John Wilkinson, 


(( 


Horace White, Esq., 


u 


Hamilton White, Esq., 


n 


F. A Marsh, Esq., 


u 


George Saul, Esq., 


(C 


Dudley P. Phelps, Esq., 


(( 


Hon. Thomas Y. How, Jr., 


Auburn. 


Hon. William H. Seward, 


u 


Col. Clarence A. Seward, 


u 


Nelson Beardsley, Esq.," 


a 


Stephen A. Goodwin, Esq , 


u 


Hon. George Rathburn, 


u 


Samuel Blatchford, Esq., 


u 


Parliament Bronson, Esq., 


iC 


Col. John M. Sherwood, 


ii 


Tiba A. Leland,Esq., 


ii 


Michael S. Myers, Esq., 


ii 


Hon. John Porter, 


ii 


George 0. Rathbun, Esq., 


ii 


George Underwood, Esq., 


ii. 


Hon. Warren T. Worden, 


Ii 


Theron Green, Esq., 


ii 


Hon. Christopher Morgan, (five 


copies,) " 



30 



[Assembly 



Ethan A. Worden,Esq., 
John B. Dill, Esq., 
Ira Hopkins, Esq., 
Dr. Lansingh Brings, 
William Titus, Esq., 
Col. Pomroy, 

William C. Beardsley, Esq., 
William Sutherland, Esq.,' 
Paris G. Clark, Esq., 
Rev. Dr. L. E. Lathrop, 
Rev. Henry Nelson, 
J. C. Derby, Esq., 
N. C. Miller, Esq., 
Hon. Addison Gardiner, 
Hon. Samuel L. Selden, 
E. Darwin Smith, Esq., 
Hon. G. P. Buchan, 
James C. Campbell, Esq., 
Royal Chamberlain, Esq., 
Isaac R. Elwood, Esq., 
Dr. Frank Hamilton, 
Henry C. Ives, Esq., 
Ethan A. Hopkins, Esq., 
Hon. Henry A. Rochester, 
Hon. Henry R. Selden, 
Joel P. Milliner, Esq., 
Elijah Stephens, Esq., 
Nelson Spencer, Esq., 
Daniel Warner, Esq., 
Professor Dewey, 
Dr. A. G. Tobey, 
Dr. Alexander Russell, 
Isaac Butts, Esq., 
John D. Fay, Esq., 
William Mudgett, Esq., 
Richard Vernam, Esq., 
Rev. Dr. Shaw, 
Rev. Z. Freeman, 
Dr. P. 0. Shipman, 



Auburn. 

(( 
u 
<( 

(C 

a 

a 
u 
li 

(C 

It 
u 

Rochester. 
a 

(( 

u 

a 

li 

u 

II 

li 

a 

li 

(( 

(( 

(( 

<i 

li 

ii 

ii 

11 

II 

li 

li 

u 

(C 

II 

li 



No. 136,] 



31 



Thomas R. Rochestes, Esq., 

Rufus Keeler, Esq., 

Harvey Ely, Esq., 

Thomas Kempshall, Esq., 

Hon. Orlando Hastings, 

Orsamus Turner, Esq., 

W. Barron Willard, Esq., 

0. H. Palmer, 

Hon. George W. Clinton, 

Hon. Albert H. Tracy, 

Hon. Isaac V. Vanderpool, 

Dean Richmond, Esq., 

Hon. Israel T. Hatch, 

Henry W. Rogers, 

Henry K. Smith, Esq., 

W. L. G. Smith, 

John L. Tdllcot, 

Dyre Tillinghast, 

James Wadsworth, Esq., 

Philip Dorsheimer, Esq., 

James G. Dicky, Esq., 

Gen. Nelson Randall, 

Horatio Seymour, Jr., Esq., 

Joseph G. Masten, Esq., 

John T. Hudson, 

Thomas C. Love, Esq., (family of,) 

Phocion Hoffman, Esq., 

John Ganson, Esq., 

Theodatus Burwell, Esq., 

Marshall J. Bacon, Esq., 

Sutton, Esq., 

0. H. Marshall, Esq.,- 
George Cole, Esq., 
Thaddeus W. Patchin,Esq., 
S. G. Haven, Esq., 
E. A. Maynard, Esq., 
Wm. A. Leaver, Esq., 
Hon. Millard Fillmore, 



Rochester. 



Buffalo. 



32 

Chauncey Tucker, Esq., Buffalo. 

Aurelian Conkling, Esq., " 

A. M. Clapp, Esq., u 
Hon. B. Welch, jr., (and ten copies 

for future distribution in Buffalo) " 

Rev. R. S. Storrs, Brooklyn. 

Rev. John S. Stone, « 

. Rev. Francis Vinton, " 

Rev. Henry Ward Beecher, <^ 

Rev. Samuel H. Cox, " 

Rev. J. S. Spencer, « 

Rev. Mr. Bethune, « 

Hon. John A. Lott, « 

Hon. John Vanderbilt, " 

Hon. N. B Morse, « 

Hon. Henry C. Murphy, « 

Charles R. Lynde, Esq., « 

Hon. Samuel E. Johnson, « 

Gen. H. B. Duryea, « 

Col. Philip S. Crooke, « 

Charles Lynde, u 

Commodore Boerman, u 

Col. Ward B. Burnet, « 

Rev. A. Elmendorf, « 

James Frothingham, j:sq., " 

James B. Whitcomb, n 

Rt. Rev. Bp. Loughlin, « 

Dr. John Ball, u 

Dr. Daniel E. Kissam, « 

Dr. David Atwater, u 

Dr. Daniel Ajres, jr., « 
Ledyard Lincklean, Esq., • Cazenovia. 

Hon. Henry Ten Eyck, u 

Gen. John D. Ledyard, a 

Rev. Mr. Bannister, « 

Sidney T. Fairchilds, « 

Hon. E. C. Litchfield, « 

Dennis Ledyard, Esq., a 



[Assembly 



5o. 136.] 



33 



Hon. Hiram Gardner, 


Lockport . 


Hon. Levi F. Bowen, 


a 


Hon. N'athan Dayton, 


u 


Hon. Jonathan L. Woods, 


a 


I. Dayton, 


a 


Charles J. Fox, Esq., 


<c 


J. M, Hamilton, Esq., 


u 


Job W. Vail, Esq., 


Cl 


Arthur W. Fox, Esq., 


iC 


Wm. S. Farnell, Esq., 


u 


Hon. T. B. Mitchell, 


Canajoharie. 


Charles Sacia, Esq., 


•(( 


Giles F. Van Vechten, Esq., 


« 


Hon. George Yost, 


Fort Plain. 


Daniel G, Lobdell, Esq., 


c( 


Hon. Charles H. Ruggles, 


Poughkeepsie 


Seward Barculo,Esq., 


ii 


V. P. Bonesteel, Esq., 


a 


E. A. Buttolph, Esq., 


a 


R. D. Davis, Esq., 


u 


Hon. Gilbert Dean, 


■« 


Gen. Davies," 


a 


Hon. Levinus Monson, 


Hobart. 


Hon. Nelson K. Wheeler, 


Deposit. 


Hon. S. C. Johnson, 


Delhi. 


Robert Parker, Esq., 


u 


Hon. Samuel Gordon, 


c( 


Alber: Edgerton, Esq., 


il 




U 


James R. Allaben, Esq., 


» 


Truman H. Wheeler, Esq., 


(C 


Hon. John Tracy, 


Oxford. 


Hon. James Clapp, 


u 


Hon. Henry Vanderlyn, 


u 


Ransom Balcom, Esq., 


a 


Henry R. Mygatt, Esq., 


u 


James W. Glover, Esq., 


a 


Dr. W. G. Sands, 


u 


[Assembly, No 130.] 3 





34 



[Assembly 



Hon. S. M. Purdy, Norwich. 

Benjamin F. Rexford, Esq., " 

Elisha B. Smith, Esq., " 

John Randall, Esq., " 

Hon. Abial Cook, " 

Hon. Charles Yorke, " 

Ezra Hewett, Esq., '' 

Burr B. Andrews, Esq., 

Hon. Henry Bennett, 

Albert Pritchard, Esq., 

Roswell K. Bourne, 

Ozias Bush, Esq*., 

Hon. Hiram Gray, 

Alexanders. Divan, Esq., 

S. G-. Hathaway, jr., Esq., 

Hon. A. S. Thurston, 

John Arnot, Esq., 

James L. Woods, Esq., 

Samuel Ross, Esq., 

Rhodes, Esq., 

Elijah Jones, Esq., " 

Hon. Daniel S. Dickinson, Binghamton. 
Giles W. Hotchkiss, " 

Ausburn,Birdsall, " 

John Clapp, Esq., " 

Jacob Morris, Esq., " 

Hon. John A. Collier, " 

Morris, Esq., " 

James Hawley, Esq., " 

Clifton Hall, Esq., " 

Hon. Martin Grover, Angelica. 

Hon. M. B. Champlin, Cuba. 

Hon. Wm. P. Angle, Ellicottville. 

Daniel R. Wheeler, " 

Robert H. Shankland, " 

George M. Beck with, Esq., Plattsburgh. 

Col. R. G. Stone, « 

Hon. Lemuel Stetson, " 



New Berlin. 

u 

Pitcher. 

Guilford. 

Elmira. 
(( 

a 

u 

u 

u 

a 

a 



No. 136.] 35 



Prof. Joseph W. Taylor, 


Plattsburgh, 


Charles Kean, Esq., 


(( 


P. O'Mara, Esq., 


u 


Seth Stone, Esq., 


u 


Michael Cosgrove, Esq., 


u 



Hon. Martin Van Buren, Kinderhook. 

Dr. J. P. Beekman, " 

Hon. N. S. Benton, Little Falls. 

Hon. Arpliaxed Loomis, " 

Hon. DeWitt C. West, Carthage. 

Hon. A. C. Hand, Elizabethtown. 

Joseph R. Flanders, Esq., Malone. 

Hon. Daniel Cady, Johnstown. 

Hon. Benjamin Pringle, Batavia. 

Hon. Zadoc Pratt, Prattsville. 

Hon. Lyman Tremaine, Durham. 

Hon. Charles Smith, Cape Vincent. 

Jacob Brown Kirby, Brownville. 

Kirby, " 

James H. Starbuck, Watertown. 

Joshua Morre, " 

Joseph Mullen, Esq., " 

J. W. Tamblin,Esq., " 

Lawrence J. Goodale, " 
Dr. Reuben Goodale, " 

Walter N. Woodruff, Esq., « 
James M. Clark, Esq. " 
Hon. Killian Miller, Hudson. 
Hon. Henry Hogeboom, " 
Hon. Darius Peck, " 

John Gaul, Jr. Esq., " 

Dr. Robert G. Frary, " 

Dr. Elbridge Simpson, " 
Rev. Mr. Watson, " 

Rev. Mr. Brown, " 

Josiah W. Fairchild, Esq., " 
John S. Anable, Esq. " 

Hon. John T. Hogeboom, Gitent 



36 [Assembly 



jHon. A. B. Conger, Haverstraw, 

Hon. IS'athaniel Jones, Newburgh. 

Hon. E. W. Rogers, Wliallonsburgh, 

Hon. Henry E. Bartlet, Walton. 

Hon. Harmon Bennet, New Lisbon. 

Hon. Nathan Bristol, Factoryville. 

Hon. F. R. E. Cornell, Addison. 

Hon. J. A. McElwain, Warsaw. 

Hon. Isaiah Blood, Ballston Spa. 

Hon. Wm. Miner, New- York. 

Hon. P. C. Maloney, " 

Hon. A. H. Mo^, Lockport. 

Hon. J. Rose, Jr., New-York. 

Hon. Russel Smith, " 

Hon. Smith Stilwell, Ogdensburgh. 

Wm. G. Cooper, Esq., Rochester. 

P. Tucker, Esq., Palmyra. 

Lewis F. Allen, Esq., Black Rock. 

Hon. E. S. Marsh, Groton. 

Wm. Brown, Esq., Brookfield. 

Robert Brown, Esq., " 

Grant E. Garlock, Esq., Auburn. 

H. Strues, Esq., Youngstown. 

H. P. Bigelow, Esq., Cazenovia. 

Major Beal, U. S. A. 

Dr. E. B. O'Callaghan, (6 copies,) Albany. 

Sherrill, Esq., Lake George. 

German Thompson, Esq., Baldwinsville. 
Parker, Hamilton. 



Col. Sage, Troy. 
♦ Wm. Landon, Albany, 
Wm. Mitchell, " 
Wm. C. Dryer, Esq., Victor. 
Thomas F. Davis, Esq., Syracuse. 
Herrick Allen, Esq., " 

Alanson Coats, Esq., " 

Hon. Ira Harris, Albany. 
M. Worcester, " , * , 



No. 136. J 37 

B- Molinard, Albany. 

Wm. Griffin, Jr., « 

T. Roessle, Esq., " 

E. S, Doty, Esq., Eome. 

Lieut. Delos B. Sackett, U. S. A. • 

Samuel R. Brown, Esq., Auburn. 

E. T. T. Martin, Esq.. ," 

Jeremiah Reynolds, Esq., Saugerties, 

Gen. Vincent G. Barney, Newark. 

Orrin Britt, Esq., Medina. 

J. M. Morrison, Esq., Manhattan. 

Nicholas Devereaux, Esq., Utica. 

L. M. Fuller, Skaneateles. 

Rev. F. R. Cornell, Manhattan. 

S. R. Ward, Esq., Rome. 

J. Elmendorf Ostrander, Esq., Kingston. 

Wm. Eno, Esq., Pine Plains. 

Wm. Kelly, Esq., Rhinebeck. 

Mr. Tallman, (Surrogate,) Poughkeepsie 

James Mabbet, Esq., Mabbetsville. 

Wm. Chamberlain, Esq., Red Hook. 

V/heel^' H. Bristol, Esq., Orange co. 

Hon. James Maurice, Williamsburgh. 

Nicholson P. O'Brien, Esq., " 

Hon. Wm. Collins, Lowville. 

Hon. Francis Seger, Martinsbur^h. 

Wm. H. C. Hosmer, Esq., Avon. 

Hon. James S. Wadsworth, Geneseo. 

Hon. Amos A. Hendee, " 

Mrs. John Young, «' 

Hon. Thomas Barlow, Canastota. 

Hon. Charles Mason, Hamilton. 

Col. Thomas Nye,' « 

J. P. Whittemore, Esq., " 

Joseph Mason, Jr., " 

Jer-miah Wilber, '* 

Gen. Zadoc T. Bentley, Morrisville. 

C. P. Johnson, Esq., Berkshire. 



38 [Aksembly 

Abel Heald, Esq., Sempronius. 
Hon. Gerrit Smith, Peterboro'. 
Joseph 0. Wright, Esq., Baldwinsville. 
Jacob Young, Esq., Marlborough. 
Professor Root, Hamilton College, Clinton. 
Professor A. J. Upson, " " 

Professor C. Avery, " " 

Hon. Elisha W. Sheldon, Sennett. 
George Halsey, Esq., Suffolli C. H. 

C. J. Stillman, Esq., Cooperstown. 
Daniel Watrous, Esq., Lyons. 

W. Smith, Ingham, Esq., Cato Four Corners. 
Wm. Burk, Esq., « 

Israel E. Phelps, Esq., " 

D. W. Emerick, Esq., " 
Hon. Freeborn J. Jewett, Skaneateles. 
William Fuller, Esq., " 

F. V. D. Horton, Esq., « 
Wm. H. Jewett, Esq., " 
Horace Hazen, Esq., " 
Joel Thayer, Esq., « 
John Legg, Esq., " 
Dr. E. H. Porter, " 
Hon. Milton A. Kinney, " 
Hon. Edwin B. Morgan, Aurora. 
Hon. Henry Morgan, " 
Charles Richmond, Esq., " 
Wm. H. Bogart, Esq., " 
Gordon H. Clark, Esq., Auburn. 
Doctor Darius Clark, Canton. 

G. L. Watkins, Esq., Scipioville. 

James France, (2 sets for operatives in factories,) Schoharie. 

Hon. Wm. Collins, Lowville. 

A. C. Nelson, Esq., Keeseville. 

Hon. Alouzo C. Paige, Schenectady. 

H. Ramsdell, Esq., Banker, Newburgh. 

Alfred Post, Esq., " ' 

J. H. Fonda, Esq., " " 



No. 136.] 



39 



J. S. Smith, Esq., 


Banker 


, Kingston. 


E. W. Farrington, Esq., 


u 


Newburgh. 


A. Ayrault, Esq., 


u 


Geneseo. 


H. B. Gibson, Esq., 


ii 


Canandaigua 


T. H. Rochester, Esq., 


ii 


Rochester. 


Freeman Clark, Esq., 


u 


a 


S. S. Day, Esq., 


u 


Catskill. 


John S. Ganson, Esq., 


I'. 


Buffalo. 


William R. Randall, Esq., 


> 


Cortland. 


Walter M. Conkey, Esq., 


(( 


Norwich. 


C. 0. Hdsted, Esq., 


C( 


New-York, 


G. B. Lamar, Esq., 


(( 


a 


F. W. Edmonds, Esq., 


(( 


u 


D. R. Martin, Esq., 


» 


ii 


C. W. Lawrence, Esq., 


u 


a 


S. Knapp, Esq., 


ii 


it 


James Van Nostrand, Esq. 


Ii 


a 


A. B. Hays, Esq., 


ii 


a 


T. R. Acly, Esq., 


a 


ii 


H. F. Vail, Esq., 


a 


ii 


A. P. Halsey, Esq., 


a 


a 


N. G. Bradford, Esq., 


u 


a 


G. A. Worth, Esq., 


ii 


a 


E.G. Drake, Esq., 


a 


a 


Geo. Curtis. Esq., 


ii 


a 


Samuel B. WTiite, Esq., 


a 


ii 


J. E. Williams, Esq., 


i( 


a 


Dr. William Taylor, 




Manlius. 


Dr. Alexander Thompson, 




Aurora. 


Dr. P. H. Hard, 




Oswego. 


Dr. A. Van Dyke, 




ii 


Dr. S. Hart, 




a 


Dr. Bryant Burwell, 




Buffalo. 


Dr. Austin Flint, 




u 


Dr. Corydon La Ford, 




Lockport. 


Dr. Jonathan Kneeland, 




Borodino. 


Dr. Nelson Wintor, 




Havanna. 


Dr. S. Pardee, 




Fulton* 



40 



[AsSEMBLlf 



Dr. Edson Carr, 
Dr. A. Niles, 
Dr. Morgan Snyder, 
Dr. Amasa Trowbridge, 
Dr. Jenks S. Sprague, 
Dr. Luke J. Tefft, 
Dr. Daniel Dennison, 
Dr. Luther Guiteau, 
Dr. Samuel Sluimway, 
Dr. Horace Nelson, 
Dr. John N. Todd, 
Dr. D. F. Jones, 
Dr. Hiram Adams, 
Dr. W. F, Cooper, 
Dr. Frederick Hyde, 
Dr. Phineas H. Burdick, 
Dr. C. M. Kingman, 

Dr. Eldridge, 

Dr. Horace Bronson, 
Dr. Miles Goodyear, 
Dr. George W. Bradford, 
Dr. Ashbel Patterson, 
Dr. Lewis Riggs, 
Dr. Ferris Jacobs, 
Dr. Simeon Snow, 
Dr. E. C. Kimball, 
Dr. Wm. S. Purple, 
Dr. Levi Farr, 
Dr. Henry Mitchell, 
Dr. John Campbell, 
Dr. Valentine Mott, 
Dr. John W. Francis, 
Dr. John C. Cheeseman, 
Dr. David M. Reese, 
Dr. Willard Parker, 
Dr. Horace Green, 
Dr. Gurdon Buck, 
Dr. Edward D. Coventry, 



Canandaigua. 

Bath. 

Fort Plain. 

Watertown. 

Winfield. 

Marseilles. 

Oran. 

Trenton. 

Schroon. 

Plattsburgh. 

Baldwinsville. 

a 

Fabius. 

Kelloggsville. 

Cortlandville. 

Preble. 

McGrawville 

Cincinnatus. 

Virgil. 

Cortlandville. 

Homer. 



Delhi. 

Palatine Bridge. 
Cato. 
Greene. 
Greene. 
Norwich. 
U. S. A. 
New- York. 

cc 

u 

a 

u 

u 

iC 

u 



No. 136.] 41 

Dr. Edward Delafield, New- York. 

Dr. Gunning S. Bedford, " " 

Dr. John N. Carnochan, " 

Dr. William Darling, « 

Dr. Edmund G. Rawson, " 

Dr. Francis W. Johnson, " 

Dr. James R. Wood, " 

Dr. Alfred C. Post, " 

Dr. John W. Draper, " 

Dr. Joseph M. Smith, « 

Dr. John Watson, " * 

Dr. Richard K. Hoffman, « 

Dr. Isaac Wood, « 

Dr. Fordyce B. Barker, " 

Dr. Edward Bayard, " 

Dr. Thomas Cook, * « 

Dr. Martyn Payne, " 

Dr. Galen Carter, " 

Dr. Alexander F. Vache, " 

Dr. Edward Ruggles, " 

Dr. John H. Griscom, " 

Dr. Alexander E. Hosack, « 

Dr. Hugh Sweeney, « 

Dr. Jackson Stewart, " 

Dr. Henry De inison, 
Joseph McKeen, Esq., N. Y. 

Schools, 
Thomas W. Valentine, Esq., 
George W. PI} mptou, 
Amos W. Kellogg, 
Sumner C. Webb, 
Truman H. Bowen, 
Charles R. Coburn, 
Emerson J. Hamilton, Esq,, 
L. G. Corey, Esq., 
James Johonnot, Esq., 
Levi Johnson Esq., 
O.Morehouse, Esq., 



Syracuse. 


city, Sup't 






New- York 


Teachei 


', Albany. 


do 


do 


do 


do 


do 


do 


do 


do 


do 


Binghamto 


do 


Bath. 


do 


Hudson. 


do 


Syracuse. 


do 


Auburn. 


do 


Albion. 



42 



[Assembly 



Solomon Jenner, Esq., 

John W. Bulkley, Esq., 

James H. Hardy, Esq., 

William Smith, Esq., 

Xenophon Haywood, Esq., 

L. Marshall Ingalls, Esq., 

Samuel G. Love, Esq., 

Abram Van Valin, Esq., 

E. D. Weller, Esq., 

Samuel C. J. Sweezey,Esq., 

E. A. Sheldoii, Esq., 

H. G. Abbey, Esq., 

L. A. Young, Esq., 

Rev. Moses Crow, Esq., 

J. G. Ogden, Esq., 

S. B. Cole, Esq., 

H. W. Allen, Esq., 

G. D. Reynolds, Esq., 

E. J. Snook, Esq., 

J. Winslow, Esq., 

D. W. Blanchard, Esq., 

D. M. Pitcher, Esq., 

Principal of Public School, 

W. V. R. Smith, Esqr., 

H. E. Pitcher, Esq., 

Wm. W. Newman, Esq., 

Mr. Rice, City Superintendent, 

Editor Geneva Gazette, Geneva. 

Oswego Palladium, Oswego. 

Gazette, Cherry Valley. 

Post, Troy. 

Republican, Ogdensburgh. 

Democrat, Lansingburgh. 

Republican, Saratoga Springs. 

Chronicle, Ithaca. 

Republican, Glens Falls. 

Herald, Sing Sing. 

Eastern State Journal, Sing Sing. 



T eachei 


', New- York. 


do 


Williamsburgh, 


do 


Elmira. 


do 


Owego. 


do 


Troy. 


do 


Canajoharie. 


do 


Randolph. 


do 


Poughkeepsie. 


do 


Mt. Morris, 


do 


Greenport. 


do 


Oswego. 


do 


Brooklyn. 


do 


Schenectady. 


do 


Lima. 


do 


Bingamton. 


do 


Prattsburgh. 


do 


Elmira. 


do 


Fair mount. 


do 


Weedsport. 


do 


Watertown. 


do 


Waterloo. 


do 


Owego. 


do 


Ithaca. 


do 


Rome. 


do 


Burton. 


do 


Buffalo. 


do 


Buffalo. 



No. 136.] 43 

Editor Democrat, Huntington. 

Courier, Bath. 

Advertiser, Owego. 

Republican, Bingharaton. 

Fredonia Censor, Fredonia. 

Buffalo Express, Buffalo. 

Democrat, (S. P. Allen, Esq.,) Rochester. 

Whig, (R. L. Adams, Esq.,) Lyons. 

Allegany Co. Whig, Angelica. 

Journal, Syracuse. 

Yates Co. Whig, Penn Yan. 

Journal, (A. W. Clark, Esq.,) Watertown. 

Morning Herald, Utica. 

of N. Y. Evening Post, New-York. 

True National Democrat, New- York. 
National Democrat, " 

Herald, " 

Times, " 

Tribune, " 

Express, " 

Courier and Enquirer, " 

Commercial Advertiser, " 

.Journal of Commerce, *■ 

Truth Teller, " 

Courier des Etats Unis, " 

Staats Zeitung, " 

Sun, " 

Democrat 



5 

Sunday Atlas, 
Spirit of the Times, 
Home Journal, 
Scientific American, 
Albion, 
Observer, 
Evangelist, 
Merchants' Magazine, 
Freeman's Journal, 
Celt, 



44 [ASSEMBL 

Editor of N. Y. Christian Enquirer, New- York. 

Christian Advocate, " 

American Messenger, " 

Morning Star, " 

Mirror, « 

Golden Rule, " 

Military and Naval Argus, " 
Weekly Universe, " 

L' Eco d' Italia, « 

National Police Gazette, " 

Christian Intelligencer, " 

Churchman, " 

Sunday Dispatch, " 

Times and Messenger, " 

Sunday School Advocate, " 

Western World, " 

U. S. Journal, " 

' Cosmopolite, '' 

Merry's Museum, " 

American Railroad Guide, " 
Foreign Missionary, " 

Home Missionary, '' . 

Knickerbocker Magazine, " 

Editor of Republican, Albion. 

Democrat, Batavia. 

Republican Era, Oramel. 

Advocate, Bath, 

Democrat, Dansville. 

Messenger, Canandaigua. 

Atlas, Phelps. 

Sentinel, Palmyra 

Democrat, Newark. 

Observer, Waterloo. 

New Era, Auburn. 

Journal, Ithaca. 

Gazette, Elmira. 

Democrat, Skaneateles. 

Democrat, Penn Yan. 



No. 136.] 45 

Editor of Union, Rochester. 

Budget, Troy. 

Times, Troy. 

Journal, Olean. 

Union Democrat, Deposit. 

Telegraph, Granville. 

Democrat, Pulaski. 

Ind. Republican, Goshen. 

Telegraph, Poughkeepsie. 

Democratic Freeman, Hudson. 

Gazette, Lyons. 

Telegraph, Newburgh. 

The Independent, Brooklyn. 

Advertiser, Rouse's Point. 

Union, Norwich. 

— — (E. Max Leal, Esq.,) Norwich. 

American Agriculturist, New-Yark. 

Courier, Seneca Falls. 

Whig, (Mr. Horton) Fultcnville. 

Republican, Cooperstown. 

Eagle and Journal, Poughkeepsie. 

Ogdensburgh Sentinel (Mr. Foot) Ogdensburgh. 

Green County Whig, (Mr. Gunn) CatsklU. 

Kingston Journal, Kingston. 

Daily Advertiser, Auburn. 

Daily Journal, Oswego. 

Courier, (Mr Hagerman) Rondout. 

Schoharie Republican, Schoharie. 

Bingham(on Demorat, Binghamlon. 

Cayuga Chief, Auburn. 

Delaware Gazette, Delhi. 

Commercial Advertiser, Buffalo. 

Buffalo Courier, " 

Welsburger Gazette, " 

Buffalo Repubic, " 

Franklin Gazette, Malone. 

Spirit of the Times, Batavia. 

Freeman's Journal, Cooperstown. 

^ (Mr. Joesbury) Catskill. 



46 [Assembly 



Editor of Prattsville Advocate, Prattsville. 

Republican, (S. S. Hommel) Kingston. 

Mohawk Courier, Little Falls. 

Jefifersonian, Water town. 

Brooklyn Eagle, Brooklyn. 

Independent, Williamsburgh. 

Lewis County Republican, Lowville. 

Lewis County Democrat, Martinsburgh. 

Madison Observer, Morrisville. 

Reflector, Hamilton. 

Phoenix, Chittenango. 

Rural New-Yorker, Rochester. 

Cultivator, Albany. 
Rev. Wm. C. Boyce, Maine. 
Rev. David D. Demarest, Hudson. 
Rev. y. M. Hulbert, Yonkers. 
Rev. Henry Ostrander, Saugerties. 
Rev. Thomas K. Fessenden, Homer. 
Rev. Elias Bowen, Cortland. 
Rev. Hercules R. Dunham, Cortland. 
Rev. Henry Bowen, " 

Rev. Daniel. Coft, Norwich. 
Rev. Dr. Thompson, Buffalo. 
Rev. Dr. Hay, Oswego. 
Rav. Dr. Murdock, Elmira. 
Rev. Dr. Condit, Oswego. 
Rev. Mr. Griffin, Kingston. 
Rev. J. C. F. Hoes, " 
Rev. Gardiner K. Clark, Preble. 
Rev. Samuel N. Robinson, Truxton. 
Rev. Mr. Harvey, Homer. 
Rev. George Landon, Cincinnatus. 
Sanford C. Parker, Esq., Baldwinville. 
Hicks Worden, Esq., Fayetteville. 
William Porter, Esq., Jordan. 
Hon. Daniel Gott, Pompey. 
Chester Moses, Esq., Marcellus. 
Alanson Coats, Esq., Syracuse. 



No. 136.] 47 

Hon. Frederick J. Betts, Newburgli. 

Hon. John W. Brown, " 

Hon. Thomas McKissock, " 

Hon. Robert Denniston, Salisbury Mills. 

Hon. Leander Babcock, Oswego. 

Hon. Henry Fitzhugh, " 

Hon. A. P. Grant, " 

Hon. Joel Terril, ' " 

Hon. E. B. Talcott, " 

Hon. G. A. Starkweather, Cooperstown. 

Col. John H. Prentiss, " 

Hon. Schuyler Crippen, " 

Hon. Saruuel Nelson, (3 copies) " 

Lyman J. Walworth, Esq., " 

Mrs. Gen. E. B. Morehouse, " 

George Clarke, Esq., " 

Hon. John Willard, Saratoga Springs. 

Hon. R. Hyde Walworth, " 

Finlay, Esq., " 

J. A. Cory, Esq., " 

Hon. William C. Bouck, Fultonham. 
John B. Tuane, Esq., Schenectady. 
Piatt Potter, Esq., " 

Hon. G. V. Sackett, Seneca Falls. 
Henry B. Stanton, Esq., " 
Samuel D. Tillman, Esq., " 
Samuel Birdsall, Esq., Waterloo. 
Hon. Federal C. Dinning, Addison. 
Hon. Robert Campbell, Bath. 
Hon. John S. Floyd, Brookhaven. 
Duncan Bell, Esq., New- York. 
John Lefferts, Esq., Flatbursh. 
Jeremiah Johnson, Esq., " 
Hon. A. C. Niven, Monticello. • 
C. Niven, " 

Hon. Wm. Wright, Kingston. 
Hon. Marius Schoonmal<er, Kingston. 
Howard Chipp, Esq., " 



48 

Robert F. Macaulay, Esq., Kingston. 
Hon. T. R. Westbrook, " 

Hon. James C. Forsyth, « 

Hon. Lavergn Eruyn, " 

William Kerr, Esq., " 

Hon. John Van Biiren, " 

John B. Steele, Esq., " 

John H. Hasbrouck, Esq., " 

Henry H. Reynolds, Esq., " 

Col. John D. Ostrander, « 

A. Hoffman, Esq., « 

Col. Jacob H. DeWitt, « 

Cornelius Eruyn, Esq., « 

Nicholas Elmendurf, Esq., " 

Hon. "Washington Irving, Dearmans. 
Hon. James K. Paulding, Hyde Park. 
Hon. John Greig, Canandaigua. 
Lucius P. Clark, Esq., Morrisville. 
Samuel R. Ford, Esq., Newark. 
A. Hall, Esq., Whitehall. 
Wm. H. Snyder, Esq., Rosendale . 
George J. Gardiner, Esq., Syracuse. 

Adin W. Davis, Esq., '' 

Henry Onderdonk, Jr., Esq., Jamaica. 

Lieut. Gov. S. E. Church, (5 copies), Albion. 

Noah Davis, jr., Esq., Albion. 

Henry E. Sickels, Esq., Albion. 

Harry Wilbur, Esq., Batavia, 

Hon. Dibble, " 

Hon. Moses Taggart, " 

L. W. Thayer, Esq., Warsaw. 

JohnB. Skinner, Esq., Wyoming. 

John B. Skinner, 2d, Esq., Attica. 

Harvey Putnam, Esq., ' " 

James G. Hoyt, Esq., " 

Sherburne B. Piper, Esq., Lewiston. 

R. P. Marion, Esq., Jamestown. 

George Parker, Esq., Fredonia. 



^ Assembly 



No. 13G.] 49 

Thomas Grosveuor, Esq., Dunkirk. 

Madison Eur well, Esq., Jamestown. 
Austin Smith, Esq., WestiieJd." 

Eraerick A. Warren, Esq., St. Clairsville. 

James M. Smith, Esq., Buffalo. 

Elijah Ford, Esq , " 

David Van Schaack, Kinderhook. 

Richard W. Tappen, Esq., Kingston. 

Jacob Burhaus, Esq., « 

Mrs. A. Sickles, « 

Hon. George Geddes, Fairmount. 

Wheeler Truesdell, Esq., " 

James Geddes, Esq.3 « 

James M. Ellis, Esq., Onondaga. 

Seth Hutchinson, Esq.. " 

Elijah W. Curtis, Geddes. 

D. C. Lelloy, Esq., Marcel I us. 

€. H. Van Gaasbeck, Esq., Kingston. 

F. M. St. John, Esq., Monticello. 

Stephen Hamilton, Esq., Monticello. 

Richard Oakley, Esq., " 

Charles G. St. John, Esq., Vienna. 

Charles D. Roosa, Bethel. 
Walter S. Vail, Cochecton. 
Samuel M. Oldac, Esq.,Erockport. 

Carter, Esq., (Female Seminary) Albany. 

L. Brown, (Female Stminary) Albai y. 
T B. Callicot, Esq., New- York. 
Francis Rotch, Esq., Louisville. 
F. M. Rotch, Esq., " 

Lewis F. Allen, Esq., Black Rock. 
Hollis White, Esq., Niagara Falls. 
Peter A. Porter, Esq., " 

Rev. Dr. John Gosman, Kingston. 
Henry Ramsey, Esq., Schenectady. 
Wm. B. Vedder, Esq., Port Byron. 
Morris S. Kimball, Esq., Fulton. 
Daniel Richmond, Esq., Montezuma. 
[Assembly, No. 136.] 4 



50 [AsSEMBIi.¥ 



Barney S. Van Rensselaer, Esq., Albany. 
J. A. Dombrowski, Esq., " 

Aulliony Ten Eyck, Esq., " 

Henry C. Soutliwick, Esq., " 

Charles W. Ward, Esq., " 

Wm. McGourkey, Esq., " 

Wm. J. Kane, Esq., ' « 

Richard W. Murphy, Esq., « 

A. W. Eaton, Esq., " 

J. G. Curtiss, Esq., '^ 

C. H. Collins, Esq., " 
A. S. Cassidy,Esq., « 
Edward H:^.nd, Esq., " 
James Nichols, Esq., " 
Hon. Anthony Van Bergen, Coxsackie. 
Wm. Vandervoort, Esq , Tonawanda. 
Professor Tayler Lewis, Schenectady. 

D. R. Bacon, Esq., LeRoy. 
Gen. Robert Halsey, Ithaca. 
Hon. S. B. Cusliing, « 
Hon. Amaza Dana, " 
Wm. Halsey, Esq., " 
Hon. Alfred Wells, " 
Hon. Benjamin Ferris, '^ 
Moses R. Wright, Esq., " 
Wm. R. Humphrey, Esq , " 
Wm. Marsh, « 

Seymour, Esq., " 

James R. Speed, Esq., Caroline, 

E. L. B. Curtiss, Esq., South Danby. 
Hon. Calvin P. Hubbard, Brashers' Falls. 
Hon. John Leslie Russe), Canton. 

Hon. Preston King, Ogdensburgh. 
Hon. John Fine, " 

Hon Charles G. Myers, " 
Hon. A. B. James, " 

Ho;!. Francis Granger, Canandaigua. 
Hon. Albert Lester, " 

Jolia C. Sibley, Esq., « 



No. 135.] 51 

E. G. Lapliam, Esq., Cananda^'gua. 
Hon. Alvah Worden, " 

Rt. Rev. Bp. Delancy, Geneva. 
Rt. Rev. Bp. Timon, Buffalo. 
John Whiting, Esq., Geneva. 
Hon. Bcnj. Hale, (Prest. Coll.) Geneva. 
Charles S. Jenkins, Esq., Albany. 
Lemuel Jenkins,Esq., " 

Edward Tompkins, Esq., Binghamton. 
Hon. G. A. Simmons, Keeseville. 
Lysander H. Brown, Esq., Watertown. 
Hon. Isaac \V. Bishop, Granville. 
Hon. Charles Hughes, Sandy Hill. 
James H. Sherril, " 

Hon. Theron R. Strong, Palmyra. 
Hon. James C. Smith, Lyons. 
Hon. Thomas Farrington, Owego. 
Hon. John J. Taylor, " 

Hon. Stephen Strong, " 

Hon. Charles P. Avery, " 

Hon. J. M. Parker, " 

Hon. E. S, Sweet, « 

Stephen B. Leonard, Esq., " 
George S. Camp, Esq., " 

G. 0. Chase, E;q., " 

Hon. Andrew Oliver, Penn Yan. 
Hon. AVm. M. Oliver, " 
Evert Van Buren, Esq., " 
Calvin Frost, Esq., Peekskill. 
George W. Sherril, Sandy Hill. 
Wm. L. Crandall, Syracuse. 
T. R. Timley, Esq., Cato Four Corners. 
L. M.Hull ister. Esq , « 

John P. Hunter, Esq., " 

Rev. C. L Van Dyck, Marbletovi'n. 
Rev. E. Homes, Chatham Four Corners. 
Rev. M. L. Schenck, Fort Plain. 
R. W. Weir, artist, West Point. 



52 [Assembly 

Noah Kellogg, artist, Ithaca. 
George L. Clo'as;li, artist, Auburn. 
Brig. Gen. J. B. Walbacli, U. S. A. 
Brig. Gen. N. S. Clark, ^^ 

Horatio Q. Knight, 8kaneateles. 
B. Lee, Esq., " 

John G. Ellery, Esq., " 
Rev. Dr. R. Wells, Schoharie C. H. 
Harrison Sudam, Esq., Kingston. 
Levi Lawrence, Esq., Hamburg. 
Brig. Gen. Jam: s Bankhead, U. S. A. 
T. W. McMahon, Esq., Binghamton. 
John T. Headley, Esq., Newburgh. 
Henry S. Phelps, Esq., Morrisville. 
Jedediah Barber, Esq., Homer. 
Richard Beemau, Esq., " 

William Sherman, Esq., " 

William W. Northrop, Esq., " 
George Ross, E:-q., " 

Henry Sessions, Esq., " 

Hammel Thompson, Esq., " 
Manly Hobart, Esq., " 

Peter Walrod, Esq., " 

Noah Hitchcock, Jr., Esq., " 
Elijah W. Phillips, " 

Hon. E. C. Reed, " 

Lyman Hubbard, Esq., '«" 

Israel Boyce, " 

George J. J. Barber, " 

Hon. Henry Stephens, Cortland ville. 
Hon. Horatio Ballard, " 

Hon. Harmon S. Conger, " 

Gen. Roswell Randall, « 

James Sch-irmerhorn, Esq., " 
Andrew Dickson, Esq., '« 

David Hale, Esq., " 

Henry Brewtr, Esq., " 

Morgan L. Hopkins, Esq., " 



No 136.] 53 

Hiram Hopkins, Esq., Cortlandville. 
Abram Mudge, Esq., " 

Henry Crouch, Esq., " 

Eufus A. Reed, Esq., " 

Amos Rice, Esq., " 

Morgan L. Webb, Esq., « 

Anthony Freer, Esq., " 

Robert 0. Reynolds, Esq., " 
E. W. Edgcomb, Esq., " 

Charles Kingman, Esq., Cincinnatus. 
Hon. Oliver Kin man, " 

Jeremiah Eean, Esq., " 

Hon. John Gillet, Scott. 

John. W. Sharpe, Esq., " 
Hon. Ambrose S. Higgins, " 



i 



Joseph Atwater, Esq., 
Hon. John Miller, Truxton. 
Judah Pierce, 2d, Esq., " 
Wm. Blanchard, 2d, Esq., Cuyler. 
Hon. W. P. Malburne, Albany. 
Hon. H. A. Dubois, Livingston, 
Hon. J. E. Ely, Binghamton. 
Hon. D. Gilniore, Utica. 
Hon. Seymour Green, Osceola. 
Hon. S. G. Had ley, Waterloo. 
Hon. A. A. Hendee, Geneseo. 
Hon. J. V. V. Hibbard,Manlius. 
Hon. C R. Iiigalls, Greenwich. 
Hon. T. Kearney, Albany. 
Hon R. D. Livingston, New- York. 
Hon. Milhone Watson, Catskill. 
John Adams, Esq., *« 

Hon. A. H. Baily, " 

Rufiis It Kin:, E?q., « 

|AI>' ut ten Catskill names are here Avanting. 
Duncan P<^1], Esq., New-York. 
J. J. Joliiisoii, Esq., Flatbush. 
Cheney Ames, Esq., Oswego. 



54 [Assembly 



Solomon Eagle, Esq., Oswego. 
Ceylon North, Esq., Ely Creek. 
Paul Fennimore Cooper, Esq., Albany. 
Miss Cooper, Cooperstown. 
' John E. McMulion, Esq., Albany. 
Henry W. Depuy, Esq., "■ 
M. M Oicott, '* 

Jeremiah Cooper, Esq., Oneida Depot. 
Gen. J. M. McCormick, Ithaca. 
Levi Lawrence, Esq., Hamburgh. 
Philip Schuyler, Esq., Pelhara. 
Joshua Loornis, Esq., New Rochelle. 
Nathan Bell, Esq., " 

I Three New Rochelle names lost.] 
A. Churchill, Esq., Utica. 
Albert G. Carll, Esq., Jericho. 
Hon. William L. Marcy, Albany. 
Hon. James M. French, " 
Abel French, Esq., " 

John D. Norton, Esq., Syracuse. 
David W. Greenman, McGrawviUe. 
Stephen Kellogg, Esq., Taylor. 
Sheldon Warner, Esq., " 
Garret Pretchard, Esq., Solon. 
Johns. Dyer, Esq., Willet. 

Joseph Green, Esq., " 

William Church, Esq., Marathon. 

James Comsiock, Esq., " 

Dann C. Squires, Esq., Lapeer. 

Hon. Wm. H. Ludlow, Sayville. 

Major Zenas C. Priest, Little Falls. 

Messrs. Goodyear & Martin, Schoharie. 

Theodord Miller, Esq., Hudson. 

Rev. Mr. Howard, " 

Rev. L. II. Van Dyck, Guilderland Centre. 

Gen. Samuel G. Hathaway, Solon. 

John L. Boyd, Esq., " 

Messrs. Crooke & Palmer, Albany. 



No. 136,] 55 

Sayles, Esq., (IIG Pier,) Albany. 

Graham, Esq., " " 

Alderman Goddard, " 

Timothy Hosmer, Esq., Lockport. 
H. A. Tilden, Esq., New Lebanon. 
S. A. Law, Esq., Meredith. 
Wm. Curtis Noyes, Esq., New-York. 
Rev. James B. Ten Eyck, St. Andrews. 
D. K. Olney, Esq , Windham Centre. 
Hon. Frederick A. Fenn, Prattsville. 
Wm. E. Leet, Esq., Coxsackie. 
Jeremiah Russell, Esq., Tivoli Depot. 
John G. Orton, Esq., Lisle. 
F. W. Willard, Esq., Lowville. 
Hon. Thomas L Chatfield, Owego. 
William F. Warner, Esq., " 
C. C. Wasson, Esq., Albany. 
Thomas Wheeler, Esq., Syracuse. 
<x. F. Comstock, Esq., do 
Rev. Dr. M. MtLaren, Newburgh. 
John L. Swits, Schenectady. 
Dwight H. Clarke, Oxford. 
Daniel A. BiUterfield, Utica. 
Hon. 0. S. Williams, Clinton. 
Gen. Francis E. Spinner, Mohawk. 
Lawrence Eellinger, Esq., " 
Jacob Spinner, Esq., " 

William Keep, Esq., Lockport. 
William C. Barber, Auburn.s 
Wm. B. Gilbert, Syracuse. 
Hon. Joseph Fellows, Geneva. 
Oliver H. Palmer, Esq., Rochester. 
Hon. Luther C. Peck, Nunda. 
William H. Adams, Esq., Lyons. 
Hon. George Hastings, Moscow. 
Hon Reuben H. Fenton, Frewsburgh. 
Hon. .loseph Centre, Lockport. 
William C. Bryant, Batavia. 



56 [ASSEMBLT 



Reuben Bryant, Albion. 

r. J. Frithian, Esq., Lockport. 

Jeremiah Osborne, Esq., Albany. 

Rev. Dr. 0. H. Gregory, West Troy. 

Hon. Nicholas P. Tiist, New- York. 

Publisher of Newburgh Telegraph, Newburgb. 

Nathan B. Wilber, Esq., Oneida Depot. 

Chauncey L. Grant, Esq., Itliaca, 

Samuel H. VVinton, Esq., " 

Alfred B. Field, Esq., Canandaigua. 

Robert Randall, Brookfield. 

Alvan Randall, " 

John Eddy, Esq., Milford. 

A. T. Drake, Esq., LeRoy. 

L. H. Turner, E.-q., Hoisehcads. 

Dr. E. D. Williams, Elbridge: 

Jndr,e Hiiani Kinue, Cocperstown. 

James D. Ford, Esq , Newark. 

E. H. Rock wood, " 

Dr. John L. Danlap, Watertown. 

Editor Brockport Weekly Journal, BrockpeiL 

Joseph Juliand, Esq., Greene. 

Hon. K(^bert .Monell, " 

S. S. Nich.dls, Esq., " 

Hon. Tliomas Barlow, Canastota. 

M. S. Tilden, Esq., New Lebonon. 

John Leslie RiisseJJ, Esq., Canton. 

H. C. Ball, Esq. New Lebanon. 

Dr. John Cam})bell, U. S. Army. 

James ; atterlee, Esq., New-York. 

Hon. II. W. Jackson, Havanna. 

A. G. Chee.'^^i. rough, E^-q., Canandaigua, 

Samuel De Wvl;', Csq., B!id;;iewattr. 

J. A. Nexsen, E\-., .New York. 

Titiany L .w^er, Esq., Law} orsville. 

Hon. Sterling (^ Hadlt-y, Wuierloo. 

R. D. (^ook, Esq., Cayuga. 

T. W. :ileMah.nj,Binghaniton. 



No. 136. j 57 

William Peck, Esq., Buifalo. 
Isaiah Townsend, Esq., Cornwall. 
Hon. James M. Cook, Saratoga. 
Hiram Barney, Esq., Brooklyn. 

I^ipley, Esq., New- York. 

McElrath, Esq., " 

Augustus Maverick, " 

Frederick Hudson, Esq., " 

Geo. D. Butler, Esq., " 

Maj. Gen. Winfield Scott, U. S. A. 

Rev. Dr. Eliphalet Nott, Schenectady. 

Prof. Jackson, " 

Prof. Thomas Read, Geneva. 

Thomas M. Deane, West Troy. 

Rev. Dr. T. N. Strong, Flatbush. 

Rev. Dr. R. 0. Currie, New-Utrecht. 

Rev. E. S. Porter, Williamsburgh. 

Rev. A. W. Mann, Poughkeepsie. 

Rev. Heniy Ludlow, " 

John Cuyler, Esq., Albany. 

J. Earl Hulbert, Boonville. 

Richard Hulbert, Esq., " 

Morgan L. Schemerhornj Esq., Albany. 

Peter Keyser, Esq., " 

Dennis B. Gafi'ney, Esq., " 

Brace Millard, Esq., Niagara co. 

E. D. Worcester, Esq., Albany. 

Peter B. YattJ, Esq., Scher.ectady. 

Samuel D. Enos, Esq., De Ruytcr. 

Hon. William Enos, " 

Asa W. Lee, Esq., Albany. 

Calvin M. Wright, Esq., Schenectady. 

William Bamber, Esq., Boonville. 

Charles H. Holt. Syracuse. 

Beverly R. Hasbrouck, Kington. 

Cornelius Glen, Albany. 

Walton Swetland, Esq., Freetown. 

Solomon K. Stevens, Esq., Texas Valley. 



58 [Assembly 

Charles Davis, Esq., Harford. 

James H. Ileaton, Esq., " 

Page Green, Esq., Virgil. 

Plato F. Grow, E^q., " 

Geo. M. Tanner, Esq., " 

Nathan Bonton, " 

Richard U. Sherman, Esq., Utica. 

Wm. Effingham Lawrence, Esq., Long Island. 

John D. Norton, Esq., Syracuse. 

— Coats, Esq., Fulton. 

Prof. James Hall, Albany. 

Grand Sachem, Ely Parker, Rochester. 

Hon. A. H. Hovey, Syracuse. 

Hon. Thomas G. Alvord, " 

Colonel North, Cooperstown. 

Wm. C. Barber, Esq., Auburn. 

Gen. L. Ward Smiih, Rochester. 

Gen. L. Ward Smiih (for Mr. Archer), Rochester. 

Col. H. S. Lansing, Syracuse. 

John S. Paler, Esq., Medina. 

H. Davis, Esq., Waterville. 

J. C. Greenwood, Glenn's Falls. 

Henry Hilton, Esq., New York. 

J. M. Hatch, Esq., Rochester. 

Robert Howell, Esq., Nichols. 

Henry A. Tilden, Esq., New- Lebanon. 

J. M. D, Carr, Norwich. 

W. M. Beauchamp, Skaneateles. 

George Harrington, Esq., Auburn. 

Hon. John A. King, L. I. 

H. H. Hay, Esq., Mount Morris. 

D E. Havens, Esq., Weedsport. 

Ira P. Barnes, Esq., Sherburne. 

Francis Skillman, Esq ,Roslyn. 

Henry Wells, Esq., Aurora. 

M. Wells, Aurora. 

Hon. Peter Cooper, New-York. 

Dr. F k II. Day, Warsaw. 



No. 136, J 59 

Rev. M. Day, Wcirsaw. 

Philander B. PrincUe, Esq., Norwich. 

G. A. Lamb, Esq., Oxford. 

H. Herrington, Esq., Palmyra. 

A. J. Johnson, Esq., Greene. 

Samuel L. Olden, Brookport. 

William H. Harrison, Esq., New- York. 

Albert L. Pritchaid, Esq., New-Berlin. 

Hon. A. Lozier, Livingston county. 

Dr. E. D. Williams, Elbridge. 

J. B. Thompson, LL.D., Nerv-York. 

Hon. B. H. Streeter, Clyde. 

Moore Conger, Esq., Cato. 

Leonard 0. Aiken, Esq., Moravia. 

Stone, Esq., " 

A. Hall, Esq., Whitehall. 
Robert H. Ludlow, Esq., Westchester. 
James McQiiade, E;q., Albany. 
Nicholas Sigsliy, Esq., " 

Telii), Esq., " 

Robert Baby, " 

R. D. Coo!:, Esq., Cayuga. 
S. S. Burnliam, Esq., Watertown. 
J. F. Crawfurd, E<q , Cohoes. 

D. T. Vail, Esq , Troy. 

E. J. Horton, E>q., Peekskill. 
John Merrit, Esq., Manlius. 
Morris Bird sal!, Esq., Greene. 
Frederick S. Cozzen-, Esq., Yonkers. 
D. W. C. Stamford, Penn Yan. 
William Tinsley, Esq., Glenns Falls. 
Tunis Waldron, Esq., Waterford. 
William Kay, Esq., Molfit's Siore. 
A. G. BffirdsJey, Esq., Auburn. 

J. G. Mcrowell, Chemung. 
Richard T. Compton, New- York. 
G. A, Conovtr, Esq., " 
William H. Cornell, Esq., New-York. 



60 "[Assembly 



James Murphy, Esq., New- York. 
Joseph M. Marsh, Esq., " 
Electus B. Litchfield, « 

Hamilton Putnam, Esq., Cortlandyille. 
Edmund Stevens, Preble. 
Hon. Matthias Van Hoesen, Preble. 
James Baldwin, Preble. 
Dr. Charles Stevens, Coxsackie. 
James C. Pomroy, Esq., Cortlandville. 
James M. Burt, Esq., " 

Hon. Edward Everett, Boston, Mass. 
Hon. Rufus Choate, *' 

Hon. Marcus Morton. « 

Hon, Abbot Lawrence, " 

Hon. Josiah Quincy, Jr., « 

Hon. Robert C. Winthrop, " 
Hon. Samuel Lawrence, •' 

Hon. Charles Sumner, " 

Hon. Lemuel Shaw, " 

Hon. Samuel E. Sewall, « 

Hon. Benjamin R. Curtiss, " 
Benjamin F. Hallett, Esq., « 
William H. Prescott, Esq.^ « 
Richard H. Dana, Esq., " 

George Ticknor, Esq., " 

Edward P. Wiiippk-, Esq., « 
Rev. Dr. Lowell, « 

Epes Sargent, Esq., " 

G. B. Emerson, E~q., « 

Fletcher Webster, Esq , « 

Charles Francis Adams, Esq., " 
Lysander Spooner, Esq., " 

Hamilton Willis, E.-q., « 

Mrs. Joseph Coolidge, " 

Nahum Capen, E^q., « 

Rev. Thomas Srone King, " 

Rev. Edward Bright, « 

P. W. Parsons, Esq., « 



No. 136.] 61 

Alvan Fisher, Esq.; Boston, Mass. 

J, Harding, Esq., " 

G. P. A. Healey,Esq., " 

Hon. Theophiius Parsons, Cambridge, Mass. 

Henry W. Longfellow, Esq., " 

Hon. John G. Palfrey, « 

Rev. George E. Ellis, Charlestown, Mass. 

Rev. E. Q. Sewall, Cohasset, Mass. 

Hon. Samuel Hoar, Concord, Ma?s. 

Hon. Edward S. Moseley, Newburyport, Mass. 

Rev. lieonard Whittington, " 

Hon. George Lunt, " 

Nathaniel Hills, Esq., " 

Hon. George N. Briggs, Worcester, Mass. 

James Arnold, Esq., New Bedford, Mass. 

Hon. George Bliss, Springfield, Mass. 

G. & C. Merrlam, « 

J. Ingersoll, " 

Rev. Dr. James Kendall, Plymouth, Mass. 

Rev. Charles H. Brigham, Taunton, Mass. 

Charles Sedgwick, Esq., Lenox, Mass. 

Miss Caroline M. Sedgwick, " 

Hon. M. Fowler, Westfield,Mass. 

Rev. Cyrus Pierce, West Newtown, Mass. . 

Rev. Wm. P. Lunt, Quincy, Mass. 

Rev. Caleb Stetson, South Scituate, Mass. 

Hon. Solomon Lincoln, Higham, Mass. 

Hon. Caleb Gushing, , Mass. 

Rev. Hosea Ballon, Medford, Mass. 
Rev. Thomas Hill, Waltham, " 
Rev. John Pierpont, Medford, " 
Hon. Stephen C. Phillips, Salem, Mass. 
Rev. John S. Stone, Erookline, '' 
• J. G. Canning, Gill, " 

Hon. Edmund Quincy, Dedham, " 
Ralph T^aldo Emerson, " 

Rev. August-j^ Woodbury, Lowell, " 



62 



[Assembly 



Hon. Cliauncy F. Cleaveland, Hampton, Conn. 
Hon. Daniel P. Tyler, Brooklyn, " 

Hon. Henry Barnard, Harlford, " 

Mrs. Lydia H. Sigourney, " " 

Rev. Joel Hav/es, " " 

Rev. Horace Bushnell, " " 

Rev. Dr. Thos. Robbins, « " 

Hon. Thos. S. Williams, " " 

James H. Welles, Esq., " « 

Gov. Seymour, " " 

Hon. Thomas Barkus, West Killingly, " 
Hon. George Sharpe, Abington, " 

Hon. La Fayette S. Foster, Norvvich, " 

Charles C. Burleigh, Esq., Plainfield, " 

Dr. James B. Whitcomb, Brooklyn, " 

Rev. Charles T. Brooks, Newport, R. I. 

Rev. Dr. Francis Wayland, Providence, " 
Rev. Dr. E. B. Hall, " " 

Hon, Henry Anthony, " " 

Dr. Isaac Ray, " " 

Hon. Franklin Pierce, Concord, 
Hon. Harry Hibbard, " 

Hon. Moses Norris, 

Rev. Andrew P. Peabody, Portsmouth, 
Rev. Augustus Woodbury, Concord, 
Hon. Thomas G. Welles, Walpole, 
John G. Whittier, Esq., Amesbury, 
Hon. C. L. Knapp, Montpelier, 
Charles Chapin, Brattleboro', 
Hon. R. T. Robinson, Ferrisburgh, 
M. C. W. Wright, Shoreham, 
Joseph C. Canning, Sutherland Falls 
W. H. Flagg, Burlington, 
J. H. Allen, Esq., Bangor, 
Rev. Joseph H. Allen, " 
William Willis, Esq., Portland, 
Rev. Dr. J. Nichols, " 
John Neal, Esq., " 



N. H. 



Vermont. 



Maine. 
u 



No. 136.] 



C3 



a 
u 



Delaware. 
Maryland- 



Rev. Henry F. Edes, Eastport, Maine. 

Hon. George M. Dallas, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. 

Hon. Henry D. Gilpin, 

Hon. Charles J. Ingersoll, 

Hon. Josiah Randall, 

Hon. John Sargent, 

Wm. H. Browne, Esq., 

Hon. Horace, Binney, 

Chapman Biddle, Esq., 

Thomas Sully, Esq., " 

Hon. David Wilmot, Towanda, 

Hon. H. A. Muhlenburg, 

James Clurkson, Esq., Carbondale, 

Alexander Eryder., E^q., " 

Rev. Henry A. Riley, Montrose, 

Hon. James Campbell, 

Alvan Stevens, Esq., 

Hon. John M. Clayton, 

Hon. Roger B. Taney, 

Hon. Reverdy Johnson, 

Hon. John C. Kennedy, 

Brantz Mayer, Esq., 

Hon. John Tyler, Charles City C. H., Virginia 

Hon. Henry A. Wise, Onancook, " 

Hon. Tho's Jef 'son Randolph, Shiidwell, " 

Geo. Wythe Randolph, Richmond, " 

Prof. H. A. Washington, Williamsburgh, " 

Hon. James M. Ma?on, 

Hon. R. M. T. Hunter, 

Hon. T. H. Bayly, 

Hon. T. L. Clinghman, 

Hon. James C. Dobbin, 

W. Gillmore Simms, Esq., Midway, 

Prof. Leeber, LL. D., Charleston, 

Rev. Prof. James W. Miles, " 

Col. Arthur P. Hayne, " 

Gen. James H. Hammond, Silverton, 

Gen. D. F. Jameson, Orangeburg, 



Troy, 
New-Custle, 
Baltimore, 

a 

li 

a 



a 
a 
u 

North Carolina. 

South Carolina. 
(( 



LS,?"^ O*" CONGRESS 



64 




Col. R. F. W. Allston, Georgetown, Soutli __® ®^^ ^12 578 3 4 



Hon A. P. Butler, 

Hon. James L. Orr, 

Prof. M. Tuomey, 

Gen. Satterlee Warden, 

Rev. Mr. Rise, 

Hon. Jaraes Guthrie, 

Hon. Lynn Boyd, 

Charles Merriweather, I 

Gen. Samuel Houston, 

Hon. S. A. Douglass, 

Gen. James Shields, 

Hon. John Went worth, 

James Clapp, Jr., Esq., 

Dr. Jr'nes Campbell, 

Hon. C. L. Dunham, 

Samuel R. Ross, Esq , 

Hon. David T. Disney, 

Col. George W. Manypency, 

Hon. Henry Dodge, Wisconsin. 

Hon. Lewis Cass, Detroit, Michigan. 

Henry Polhemus, Esq., Marshall, Michigan. 

Rev. Conistock, Detroit, " 

Hon. Francis W. Sherman. Lansing, " 





Alabama. 


Port Royal, 


Tennessee. 


Clarksville, 


IC 




Kentucky. 




u 


sq., Roscoe, 


a 




Texas. 




Illinois. 




(( 


Ch-icago, 


(C 


a 


a 


Springfield, 
Portsmouth, 


u 

Indiana. 

Ohio, 
a 


mv- 


u 



Hon. Robert McClelland, 

Hon. Jefferson Davis, Mississippi. 

Hon. Thomas H. Benton, Missouri. 

Hon. JuhnC. Fremont, California. 

Professor A. D. Bache, Washington, D. C. 

Professor Beecher, " 

Archibald Campbell, Esq., " 

Hon. Charles Mason, " 

Ed. DeVerneuil, Prest. Geol. Soc. of France, Paris, France. 

Prof. Joachim Barraude, Prague, Bohemia. 

Hon. Augustus Murray, Engjish Consul General in Egypt. 

(2,061 copies in the whole.) 

Wew-York State Library, 
Albany, March 10, IS54. 

Hon E. W. Leavenworth, Secretary of State: 

Dear Sir — I l.creby certify that I have received fr.r the Regents 
of the University 50U copies of each volume of the Documentary 
History of the Slate of New^-York, partly in 8vo., a id parljT- in 
4to., from the Slate printer. 

Tc ROMEYN BECK, Secretary. 



) 




\ 



LIBRARY OF CONGRESS 



014 112 578 3 



